City April 5, 2010 12:20 PM

"Located in the Back Alley of what was Buffalo's Most Evil Square Mile"

“Located in the Back Alley of what was Buffalo’s Most Evil Square Mile”
Now that the warm weather is here and downtowners are once again making daily treks down to the Erie Basin Marina, there is a pit stop along the way that should make those walks even more enjoyable (see original post). Situated on the Seneca Street side of Pearl Street Grill and Brewery is Brawler's Back Alley Deli - a place to grab a gigantic "Real Egg" breakfast sandwich to go ($3.50), or an equally impressive brawler-sized pastrami on rye ($9.50) - tax included with orders and smaller "Girlie" sizes are available for $7.50.

What is most impressive about Brawler's is the finished deli that thinks it's a bar that thinks it's a café. I stopped in this morning before breakfast was served to order a couple of sandwiches and talked to the staff about the future of the business (that just got off the ground). Brawler's opens at 7am with coffee, croissants and muffins, breakfast sandwiches, corn beef hash, potato pancakes, bagels, etc. From there the lunch menu kicks into gear with pizzas, hot and cold sandwiches, and specialty sandwiches with names like The Lake Effect Man BLT (half pound of bacon with lettuce, tomato and mayo), The Pearlie Girl (slow roasted turkey, topped with coleslaw, and Swiss served on toasted wheat berry bread) and The Roundhouse (shaved rib eye with sautéed onions, peppers and cheese on an 8' hoagie roll with special sauce). There are some healthier choices for those looking for soups, salads and sides.

Brawlers-Bar-Buffalo-NY.jpg

The pub-style atmosphere includes plenty of booths, a bar (open for events) and an old world decor featuring endless wood and brick. Eventually the bar area will be transformed into a coffee bar with barista and specialty coffee drinks. At that point, the beer and wine will also, be served during non-event hours, but for now customers can get that type of service from any one of the other house bars. Customers can choose to eat at Brawler's, or they can grab a tray and head up to one of the Pearl Street patios. For those on the go, curbside service is available up until closing time at 3pm - why not pick up a lunch and head over to Erie Hills Park with a picnic blanket? Or for those boating on the weekdays, it's a quick trip from the lake.

At this point, Brawler's is experimenting with as many local products as possible in order to find the best quality culinary delights. If the customers approve, then the list of breads, condiments, meats, etc. will take on more of a local flavor. With the playoffs ahead, management has ordered four 50" TVs that will be installed so that Brawler's fans can enjoy all of this quality food during extended hours. Brawler's also features WiFi for anyone looking to eat and get some work done. Stop on in and make yourself at home, or grab some food for the office - whatever your pleasure, Brawler's aims to please!

Brawler's Back Alley Deli
76 1/2 Pearl Street (on the Seneca Side)
Buffalo NY 14202
716-939-3670
www.PearlStreetGrill.com  

View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Why does EVERY Restaurant in Buffalo have to offer 'LOCAL' flavor to it's menues????? Why not bring outside taste here? Not everyone is a fan of beef on weck and buffalo wings. Some of us would like some Southern and West Coast Flavors for a change.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

When Nate Appleman left A16 in SF he said: "just tell the folks out there that it's sustainably raised and local and they'll pay $40 bucks for it"....he's in NYC now. The scene out here is getting a bit ragged on (by locals) as overboard on the locavorism. In 6 months you may see the same vibe hit WNY.

I think local is great, but tastes great is better. I'm not saying import 5 lbs of beef from Argentina just for your restaurant. I'm saying saying serve the best available product without going overboard on non-local/local.

The power of words ("local"). But I have spoken visciously about the 'low' cost of food and how it has destroyed real food, in the past, so I won't be a hypocrite.

replied to Lego1981
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You know what? After a couple decades of nothing being local, seasonal or fresh I will take it. There is an endless array of uses for the large amount of food that can \ is produced around us.

Sure other foods are great and add a spice to life but we should first support our local economy before buying potatoes, corn, pork from Arizona when we can produce the same products here.

If we can't make it, then import it. If we can then we should.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I just walked down there for lunch and it was great.

Lego, I didn't notice anything obnoxiously local. As someone who's been to 38 states and just about every major city. I can honestly say The Brawler was one of the best sandwiches I've ever had. It wasn't a total NY deli, or a Philly Cheesesteak Shop but it was every bit as good as 90% of those offerings in cities known for their sandwiches. No need to worry that it's just another run of the mill sub/pizza/wing shop.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

brawler-sized pastrami on rye looks small and not that good for $12.00

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

After reading the review here, I decided to check this place out for lunch a few weeks back. The food is pretty darn good - sandwiches were good sized - but by no means huge. Here's the problem - its priced entirely way too high to make this an option when considering to go out to a deli downtown. Think of Maura's or the prices that are available at any place downtown and then add three bucks. So you end up getting less but paying much more for a sandwich (not exactly high end cuisine). Let's face it, the Globe gets away with a bit of higher prices for sandwiches because they are made with better food and have made a pretty good effort to offer something unique - this place doesn't do the same.
The sandwich was awesome, the pickle needed a bit more time in the brine but overall it was too much cash for not enough food.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll