City March 13, 2010 9:20 AM

Construction Watch: 448 Elmwood Avenue

Construction Watch: 448 Elmwood Avenue

The construction of the long anticipated mixed-use development at the corner of Elmwood and Bryant streets is well underway. After a few months of foundation work, the skeleton of the new three-story, 20,000 sq.ft. building has already brought new life to this section of the Elmwood Strip.

1.jpg

10.jpg
5.jpg
The $3.5 million project is being developed by The Krog Corp, attorney Michael Ferdman, and architect Karl Frizlen. The mixed-used structure will contain 4,300 sq.ft. of retail space along with enclosed parking on the ground floor for eight vehicles. A dozen apartment units on the second and third floors will contain between 950 and 1250 sq.ft. of living space.
elmwood-bryant-Rendering.jpg
ebfirstfloor.PNGCoffee Culture will anchor the ground floor commecial space.  Additonal space remains available.  The building is expected to be ready for occupancy this summer.
 
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Cant wait to see this finished.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's so great to see the structure being built - when compared to the KFC shack, this is going to make a HUGE impact on that stretch of Elmwood. Can we build another one where Blight Aid is located across the street? Then can we see another one go up at the Children's Hospital corner?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I 100% agree. Also the parking lot between Wilson Farms and the Globe Market next!

replied to queenseyes
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree with queenseyes and Andrew!

replied to Andrew
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It is great to see this being built. We need about 80 more of these.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Seconded!

replied to STANCSEA
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Who gets the eight parking spaces?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

awesome, awesome, awesome!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Looks great. But please put clear glass in the storefronts.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Is there an alley between the building?

I have to agree that there are many sites along Elmwood that are ripe for this kind of 3-5 story mixed use retail, office residential mix.

It also makes the much bigger case that Womens and Childrens Hospital needs to leave Elmwood Avenue and relocate to the Life Sciences Corridor with the rest of the medical professionals. Sorry but Womens and Childrens is a detriment to the community in this location because it requires to much land and as it grows it wants more land that the community cannot spare. Second the services and the specialists are in the Life Sciences Corridor and there is no room for them to co-locate at Womens and Childrens on Bryant..and why should they...when many of the services and specialists have the majority of their patients in the Life Sciences Corridor.

Wilson Farms: Goodbye
Globe Market: Goodbye
Rite Aid: Goodbye
Womens and Childrens Hospital: Goodbye

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

So you want to get rid of every store in the EV?


I'd rather concentrate on the gas station at Elmwood and Delevan or the development of the corner at Forest Ave before we talk about getting rid of stores that offer vital services like Wilson Farms.

replied to Destiny
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

sure, christine. I mean who really needs all those doctors and nurses and support staff, not to mention hospital visitors, shopping and buying lunch and cruising Elmwood, anyway? You're right: much better to kick Women's and Children's out.

replied to Destiny
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Incircles: the apartments or hotel or whatever at Forest and Elmwood is great. Add it to the list. There is no reason the businesses like Wilson Farms, Globe or Rite Aid have to close business. Its the building that people say does not belong in the community.

biniszkiewicz: look like it or not the Hospital wanted to move to the Life Sciences Corridor and is still considering moving to the Life Sciences Corridor because it reallizes LONG TERM that it is landlocked and the community is opposed to demolishing any more homes for the hospital to expand. IF CHILDRENS HOSPITAL IS GETTING OPPOSITION TO EXPAND ITS FOOTPRINT NOW ITS GOING TO BE EVEN MORE DIFFICULT IF NOT IMPOSSIBLE 10 YEARS FROM NOW AFTER MILLIONS OF DOLLARS OF INVESTMENT. THEIR NOT STUPID! Add in the fact that the special services and specialists needed to support reproduction, pregnancy and children are resident in the Life Sciences Corridor.

Mr. Bini, you can live with your head in the ground but these are facts that are blatantly obvious to the consortium of doctors that run the hospital. As far as losing the hospital patrons, again open your eyes because Elmwood is outgrowing the Buffalo State college students and its outgrowing childrens hospital. Elmwood is an older, more dense urban version of Hertel filled with more demand for residential, more demand for office space and more demand for street level retail.

You may agree or disagree but please dont call me christine or shirley or mary or barbra or debbie.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

First off, what is with the Cap Locks....is that so we can see you yelling?

Second, how is Elmwood outgrowing Buffalo State students? They are part of the fabric, do they not drink coffee, read books, eat food, drink wine, walk or bike the street? Take a look at Elmwood in the summer when school is out, a tad quieter.

I'm pretty sure everyone knows the powers that be are not stupid at the Hospital...

As to demand for street level retail, when evey storefront is rented, stores stop closing after a year or two of struggling and downsizing, then I would call it a demand for retail. Coming, but not there yet.

replied to Destiny
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

One only needs to follow the property values along Elmwood. Those higher property values mean more mature and higher income residents. Well higher than studio apartment college students. Elmwood is and has been converting to more mature businesses.

As far as stores struggling to survive, again this comes back to the higher income trend. The buildings are wrong for Elmwood and the landlords are are demanding to much $/sqft for their retail. This would not be the case if the buildings followed the Elmwood/Forest and the Elmwood/Bryant mixed use where landlords/property owners could make their profit across residential, office and retail profit streams adjusting the ue of their space as the market demands.

Retail may be questionable but office space on Elmwood is highly priced, particularly by people who live nearby. Again Elmwood is maturing. The future of Elmwood is a more urban and eclectic Hertel with a dwindling college presence.

There are big changes coming from Elmwood. Millard Fillmore Gates Circle closing, Richardson stalling, the Gates Circle Tower stalled, Elmwood/Forest Apartment stalled, Childrens Hospital (my opinion) leaving but on the positive side Canalside and the South Elmwood Parking Garage have a strong potential for connecting patrons to the Elmwood culturals.

BTW, my prediction for Millard Fillmore Gates is conversion to a hotel and conference center for Buffalo State, Canisius, Medaille and the Culturals which is sorely needed.

BTW, much of Childrens Hospital could easily be converted to residential and office space with community parking. Both hospitals could potentially add more to Elmwood than any feared loss.

Lastly, yes the Buffalo State College students are still fixtures on Elmwood but rents on Elmwood are rising while rents on Forest and Amherst and Grant are cheap, dormatories are being built on Grant...its slowly changing...but its undeniable.

Muriel Howard was an aweful detriment to Buffalo State, to the Westside and BlackRock and a horrible failure as a leader of an engine of growth for our city and region. She was proof of why patronage, tenure, unions and affirmative action produce incompetence. No patriotic american should ever apologize for the truth but if you care so little about Buffalo that you want to follow the corrupt liberal excuses Detroit follows then please visit detroit so you understand where your political and ideological insanity really produces.

replied to onestarmartin
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

are you not Chris69? aka Christine? If you don't want to be misnamed, perhaps you shouldn't attempt to change identity so often. As to the hospital. . .

women's and children's might well leave for their own reasons of space and collaboration. But if and when they do, it is foolish to imagine there won't be a hard hit to Elmwood's businesses (especially restaurants) near it. The fact that they may be inclined to relocate is hardly synonymous with kicking their butts out the door.

replied to Destiny
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Queen City> "THEIR NOT STUPID!"

Quote of the year.

replied to Destiny
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

QueenCity, I mean ChristieLou, I mean Destiny -- I like your new stripper name -- your solution to everything in Buffalo is moving large buildings or whole sections of neighborhoods to meet your back to the future visions. Of course, you never seem to think of cost or the people affected. When you're not talking about recreating elements of the Pan-Am at LaSalle Park or tearing down everything in the way of Genesee Street then you're bungling architectural terms or inventing art history.

Of course, your format is the same: over a month your screeds start in lower case, then add cap locks, then slowly build to all-out psychotic explosions of hate toward an ever-growing list of people on BRO, religions, colors and persuasions. That's when BRO presses the reset button and you invent a new identity. Let the countdown begin.

replied to Destiny
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

yeah, that pretty much sums up our obsessive little bro bigot - i mean troll.

on a different note, is it just me or do those steel members look woefully undersized?

replied to PaulBuffalo
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

How about I call you 'Muriel Howard' and be done with this.

replied to Destiny
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Buffalonian4Life, keep up the nice work with the photos.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Now I know why they don't build to the curb. This thing is a sightline albatross.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Yes, KarlMalone, the parking lots across Elmwood and across Bryant are so much nicer looking!

replied to KarlMalone
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The lots add re-contextualized urban fabric and scream post industrial green. Is that more your speed? Just saying the building is a sore thumb or an open wound. The Colonel is shedding a tear somwehere as his home was razed for this?

replied to Daniel Sack
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

don't waste your bandwidth, dan. karl's a troll. not quite in the queen city/lou/christine/destiny class but definitely an up and coming contendor for the title of biggest ***hole on bro.

replied to Daniel Sack
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Love that I get to you, grad. I love it when drama queens like youself get into a dizzie b/c i'm outside your little leftist information cocoon. Enjoy your cubicle on Monday and don't stare at your computer for more than 6 hours.

replied to grad94
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

aw, that's so sweet. i think you have a crush on me.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I hope the other 1600 sq feet of retail space available could be a KFC. We need some good food like that on this corner.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Can someone explain how this works financially?

It is a $3.5million project. So the partners put up $300,000…. that leaves a $3.2 million loan.

The payment on 3.2 million at 7% is $28,762 per month or $345,144/year.

There are 12 living units with 950-1250 sq feet each. Lets say each rent for $1200/month.

Total apartment income is $14,400/month or $172,800 per year.

There is 4,300 square feet retail. Lets say $20 per sq foot, that is $86,000/ year.

So we have income of $258,800 per year (with no vacancies).

Other expenses include water, sewer, insurance, maintenance and property taxes.

Say the building has a tax assessment of $750,000…. that is 25% of building cost equals taxes of about $35,000/ year.

Now:
The building is running at a negative cash flow of at least $10-12,000 per month.

So how does this project work financially? Who and how is it being funded?

Furthermore…. take say $150,000 away for building the retail space. That means 12 apartments cost $3.5 million minus $150k or $279,000 each. Entire houses sell (and can be built for) for much less than that.

So I challenge someone to tell me how money can be made on this project, who is making it and how it makes sense economically.

I am glad to see it happening, but the numbers do not add up.

Either some invester is getting Madoved or there is some kind of ponzi scheme going on.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I heard that the city issued a stop work order on this project because what is being built doesn't reflect what was approved by the planning board. Having seen the original elevations submitted to the city, assuming that the new version is no better (safe assumption in this case), I just wish somebody would come along and build something on this great lot that is better than this architectural monstrosity...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll