City November 17, 2009 9:20 PM

Extreme Neighborhood Makeover- Making an Extreme Difference

Extreme Neighborhood Makeover- Making an Extreme Difference

Last week's Extreme Makeover: Home Edition was a success on many levels.  Beyond the new house constructed for the Powell family at 228 Massachusetts Avenue, over 100 other homes received exterior improvements, several community gardens were planted, and a trio of murals were painted on previously graffiti-scarred walls.  Most importantly, over 5,000 residents were involved in the effort to bring hope and a brighter future to a West Side neighborhood.

Mayor Brown rallied the troops at the kick-off.  The Mayor thanked everyone "for giving of their time, heart and energy to transform a home for a deserving family, but not only to transform a home, but to transform a neighborhood.  We are going to show what Buffalo and Western New York is all about," he said, "not only nationally but internationally as well."

119157398_LQ4igc4e.jpg

And with that, work was underway.  Few imagined how the effort would grow during the course of the week. 

Harvey Garrett, who has been working tirelessly to help stabilize and turn around the West Side for several years, proudly showed off the work that was accomplished as he led me on a walk through the neighborhood.  The photos collected and used in the video below show a handful of the projects completed last week.

Garrett, Executive Director of the West Side Community Collaborative, estimates that hundreds of thousands of dollars in labor and materials was invested in improvements last week. 

But that is just the beginning.  The momentum is expected to continue and the partnerships and community involvement, if nurtured, is expected to pay dividends for years to come. 

119329444_6azhdMMp.jpg

Volunteers cleaned vacant lots, put on new roofs, painted homes and murals, installed new porches and windows, replaced fencing, installed siding, planted trees, and installed landscaping.  The City committed significant personnel and resources into the effort as well.  

Video by Nate Mroz, Buffalonian4life

Garrett described the week as "spurring a movement" in the neighborhood.  "Neighbors came together to help each other.  Before, no one had a vision for the area.  Owners were reluctant to invest in their properties due to the deteriorating condition of neighboring properties.  That has changed."

The results are impressive.  Many long-time residents described the experience as like "winning the lottery."  For the first time in years children were let out at night and were able to live life up a little in the city, said one neighborhood resident.

119443505_03MOXlLA.jpg

One house had no water for two years, and because the family didn't speak English, they couldn't get it fixed, so they ran a hose from a neighboring property for water.  Volunteers got it fixed in one day. They are forever thankful.

The success stories are seemingly endless.  Block parties are being planned.  Yards will be getting sod in the spring.  There is even talk of having a similar effort in another neighborhood next year. 

WNY helped a family and a neighborhood.  In the end it helped itself.

119446853_NqtgBQGV.jpg

Photos by Joe Cascio 

View image

2 TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.buffalorising.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/5170

As you have seen in a previous post, a lot of activity is happening in and around the Extreme Makeover neighborhood. More than just the new, innovative house built for the Powell family, the whole community is seeing a facelift, including one... Read More

The Buffalo Edition of Extreme Makeover will air on ABC on January 24th as a two-hour special, from 8 to 10PM.The show, normally one hour long, is being extended to highlight the improvements that were made in the West Side neighborhood around the subj... Read More

Comments

Leave a comment

Wow, that is a big improvement, let's not stop now, lets work towards the east untill we reach Cheektowaga!!!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Didn't ya beat this horse last week?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This project is going to spur many positive things for the city. I don't see it falling to the wayside anytime soon. To do so would disrespect all those who worked so hard.

It is important to keep it in the lime light to keep the relationships and the positive momentum going.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I spent about 45 hours on-site last week as a volunteer coordinator. It was truly a remarkable event that surprised the EMHE executives and producers. One told us that she has never seen this level of community support for a project in the history of EMHE. She was absolutely amazed at the masses of volunteers who showed up to help each day, and their willingness to go beyond the call of duty to assist neighbors and help out wherever they were needed.

I hope that we see an article like this every few days until spring 2010. I fear that we may lose momentum over the winter and lose sight of all that can be accomplished when we have a shared goal.

My only criticism is that ABC and EMHE had to be the catalyst for this to happen. I am disappoined that we could not make this happen ourselves.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Sometimes people just need an outside kick in the butt to realize what we are capable of. I agree this should have been done TV show or not but regardless now we know and have proof, for that I'm glad ABC started this. Let's just learn from this and move forward. I didn't get to help on this but I definatley would like to on future neighborhood rehabs.

replied to O'Brien
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This is unrelated but check out this article I found about the most affordable places to live.

http://realestate.msn.com/slideshow.aspx?cp-documentid=22334217>1=35000#3

Just thought I'd share.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The east side would be re-destroyed in short order. Sorry about the pessimism. The fact is its still gangland over there. Until you physically remove the gang element its like putting makeup on a pig.

I applaud all those who volunteered to help improve their city and region! Its good when good people go out of their way to right wrongs. I love this project and think it does great things for the community there but wonder a small bit if something like this sets a negative precedent, almost as if it sets an expectation that someone else will come in and fix everything, pay for everything, etc. Most have to scratch and work hard to get their "dream" home and others get for free?

Buffalo benefits from having many with big hearts and caring for their community, etc. but then there's those who don't care, they dont care about the value of a good education, dont care about their neighbors, dont care to work, and its obvious considering the condition of some of those neighborhoods.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree with most of your comments. You may not know that the gang presence is larger on the Westside than on the Eastside of Buffalo. The Westside gangs, although fewer in number, are larger in membership and power when compared to the Eastside neighborhood gangs. I don't believe that eliminating the neighborhoods on either side would eliminate the gang problem. Eliminating the gangs requires a change in policing tactics and family culture. We are in a losing battle when it is acceptable for kids and young adults to go to jail as one of their rights of passage. Parents know when their children are involved in gangs, but it is permitted and accepted. We need to change the culture if we want to change the neighborhoods. We need to increase policing and have them respond to all calls of graffiti, assaults, thefts, and threats. We need residents to feel safe if we want to improve the neighborhoods.

You wouldn't believe the number of police who were around during the EMHE event. I never felt safer walking around the neighborhoods, going to lunch, parking my car, etc than I did this past week. Unfortunately, the police have gone to wherever the police go, and it probably won't be long until the crime and quality of life issues return.

replied to flyguy
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"there are"

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Great story, a great thing that happened, BUT that video is aweful! Was Massachusetts Ave black and white and grainy in October of 2009? There was no real before and after either.

Sorry, but yes i am getting a little EMHE fatigue.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I should probably leave this to other commenters to say, but I love the video, with all of it's artful effects and its rhythm. Nate is one of the most talented teens to ever hold a camera, and I'll put his enthusiasm and trained eye up against people three times his age. Maybe you meant to say awe-full and not awful.

replied to Arch
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Unlike Arch above, I have no EMHE fatigue. And I'm still pretty sure he meant AWFUL. A Flickr link would have been better and would have made it easier to see the transition. Even a neighborhood walk while holding the camera (before and after) would have been nice. For those of us who haven't been able to see the results, this video gave very little easily discernable indication of what was transformed. The videographer's age or experience level don't matter, the video was awful, distracted and unrevealing and the editors of this site chose to put it up. When decisions are made to put this material up, people comment, hoping maybe they'll make a difference for future postings. Having the editor post a comment in defense of another commenter's criticism is unnecessary and amateurish.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

No, i meant awful. Just because he can take pretty pictures doesn't mean that this particular venture is successful. And yeah, it is a little amatuerish for you to stick up for a content provider. Maybe if you were a little more objective you would have realized that this montage says absolutley nothing about what happend over there!

For those of us who have been out of town, or are unfamiliar with the neighborhood, it would have been nice to see a true before and after.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Why? Are you suggesting that the neighborhood was better before? These people accomplished A LOT and here you are, sitting in your easy chair, curmudgeonly sniping about the production values for a nice video that apparently wasn't made at Warner Brothers Studios. What are you? Vincent Canby?

replied to Arch
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

ughh! forget it! Continue to drag BRO down with your "folksy" productions!

As far as the West side, I continiue to marvel at the legs that this project has, and hope it can manifest itself into effective gentrification...ahh i mean change.

replied to sonyactivision
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If by folksy, you mean informal and unpretentious with a feel for local culture, I guess that's been our formula since day one. I don't expect it's going to drag us down any time soon.

We'll always try to aim higher and evolve, but I don't see this video as a huge setback in our upward movement. Again, I stand by Nate and thank him for lending his time, devotion and talent to BR.

replied to Arch
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree. Nate did a nice job with the video. Those darned youngsters with all their talent and promise.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"I should probably leave this to other commenters to say"

You probably shouldn't intervene if your only goal is to deflect and discourage harsh criticism of BR content. Arch was right to speak his/her mind about the quality of the video.

Just a thought: If content is labeled something like "student work", critics may be more forgiving.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You don't blog very much, do you? A million other sites out there where being a whiny, obnoxious jerk gets you a devastating smackdown from the editors, posters, and other commenters. If you demand "editorial integrity" (whatever that is) then read the New York Times and believe every stale tidbit that doucherag serves up at $2 a pop. Being a "harsh critic" suggests that despite your tone, you are making substantial points and observations that add to the discussion. Whining about a video's production values ( it was actually fine)and content that is beyond the creative contol of anyone at BR only suggests an individual that doesn't yet know where the scroll key is. If you don't like a story, scroll on. If you expect a video short about a sweet neighborhood refresh on Buffalo's westside to come out of Pixar's CGI lab, you're living on the edge of your own Matrix wormhole.

replied to davvid
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Well, I blog enough to know that "substantial points and observations that add to the discussion" come in all shapes and sizes. Single word snarky mispelled responses are as fair as anything. The NYtimes might seem stale because it writes off too much as inconsequential noise.

My issue is more with the pressure on BR to play nice. I'm fine with moderators egaging their critics. I'm not ok with discouraging or disregarding negative comments. As an example, take the last WBFO segment when DMZ's mild "bush league" comment was held up as an example of unacceptable commenter behavior. Ironically, its the unreal :) and political correctness that probably fuels the worst "trolls" on this site.

replied to sonyactivision
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'm with you about not knowing how some comments get clipped while others, especially the race-baiting ones stand. It's probably just a matter of readers not reporting nasty stuff. And I've seen enough negative comments around here to know that BR doesn't just delete everything they don't like or that they have some 'politically correct agenda' to quash debate. I just wish this discussion was in a context other than some well-meaning kid's video. As to the NYT, most of their articles are stale because of the internet. When you know about something ten days before you read it in the Times, you have to ask yourself, why am I paying for this?

replied to davvid
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The Makeover was great, and will be a very positive highlight of the type of people we have in WNY when it airs, but the concerns voiced about certain Buffalo Neighborhoods being able to sustain any improvements are valid.

For the City to legitimately make a sustainable come back, it needs to start at home and in the schools.

I would like to see James Williams take a hard line on behavior issues. Implement a system to rank certain behaviors, and a point system that will result in removal from the regular classroom into an alternative school, with a clear path back into the regular classroom, should the student be willing to comply.

The role of the staff in the alternative school will be a combination of counseling and teaching, offering more personal attention, while not holding back students in the regular classroom. This would have to start when they are relatively young, 4th grade maybe?

Young teachers will feel comfortable working in the schools again, and the quality of instruction can improve. They may even move into the city to be closer to work.

The City will improve further when people can feel comfortable allowing their children to attend public school in Buffalo.

An actively involved community and vibrant neighborhood will force the bad element to another location where they can operate in better seclusion.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Hows this any diffrent from whats happening today? We have alternate schools.

replied to 2roadsdiverged
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The BPS code of conduct does provide alternative instruction for those students who are permanently suspended from school, but the whole structure of the penalty system is written too loosely. The reason we have mandatory sentencing integrated into our penal code is that leaving too much discretion to the judge, or in this case the superintendent results in possible disproportionate punishment. The Superintendent may go soft on the kid who attacked the teacher because his parents finally care when he's kicked out of school, and make a big deal about it.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

...and just watched it again to make sure i wasn't overreacting to criticism... and I actually feel a little nauseous.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It was a terrific job in just such a short timespan. I don't know if the same thing can be marshalled without a national TV show as a catalyst...but I wouldn't bet against Harvey Garrett and this team!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Volunteer efforts, outside of your own neighborhood, beg the question: Does the area in need lack the occasional attention of volunteers, or does it lack residents with enough income and initiative to care for their own homes? Without sufficient income to maintain the houses, no area will make progress.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

You are absolutely correct. There is no question, alot of them can't truly afford the upkeep of their houses.

Politicians can divert whatever capital they can come up with to develop our waterfront, and other projects, and people will come and visit, sure, but you won't see middle class families and young people actually moving into the city until we can find a way to fix the schools.

Maybe Buffalo's Extreme Makeover and Volunteer efforts should focus on the children of Buffalo rather than on putting lipstick on the Pig.

replied to MrGreenJeans
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The only way to "fix Buffalo" and the schools is to eradicate the poverty that has come to define much of our city. Buffalo is a warehouse for the regions poor and unless this changes we will continue to decline. As long as the poor are out of sight they are out of mind to the majority of WNY residents. There is no incentive for change since most can simply avoid the poor and associated problems. It is just too easy to to live in denial and isolation while blaming the victims. Much harder to face our own part in creating and perpetuating this separate and unequal society.

replied to 2roadsdiverged
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I would tend to disagree that Buffalo is the warehouse of the regions poor. Although the statement is correct it needs more clarifcation. Poverty has always been here, it is just that businesses, along with them, an exodus of the middle class and rich have moved out of the area in volumes. So whereas in the past there was balance (now that that is good), now there is disparity.

I wonder why businesses move out of New York State? Maybe we should enact a law requiring businesses to stay in New York State. We could enforce it by enacting a business tax to pay for the administartion costs.

replied to Blackrocklifer
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree. Middle class people don't want to raise their families near the poor welfare leaches and the problems they bring to the neighborhoods. Why do schools suck, because of the poor. Why are our streets infested with dealers and punks, because of the poor. Streets are unsafe because of the poor. Kids are beat up and robbed by the poor. Our money goes to feed the poor. Our money goes to shelter the poor. Our money goes to clothe the poor. Our money goes to buy large screen TVs for the poor. I think we do enough for the poor so we shouldn't have to live close enough to have them steal even more from us. The poor are a scourge on the earth. If you give em money they waste it then ask for more. If you give them something they expect more. There is never enough for these scumbags.

replied to KarlMalone
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Where would self righteous elitists be without the poor to look down upon? This "sho'nuf" guy, like everybody, has his flaws but they dont seem as bad to him when he is belittling the unfortunate.

replied to sho'nuff
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Grreenjeans and roaddiverged, stop asking questions and making statements that raise the issue of common sense. You might embarrass a elected official in government on any level here.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I agree with Arch. I, too, was disappointed by the video. I was hoping for a series of before/after photos side by side, so I could compare the changes. Might be a fine video, just not exactly what I was looking for.

While I grouse about that, here's more grumbling: I always mute the music on these things, too. It always annoys me. And I constantly find myself impatient waiting for the next image. I suppose I really just want slide shows, sans artistic interpretation, where I can speed through pictures as fast or slow as I like.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll