lifestyle September 24, 2009 11:11 AM

Grant Street Gallery: Zones of Discard

Grant Street Gallery: Zones of Discard

This Friday, September 25th, Viktoria Ciostek opens her photography exhibit, Zones of Discard, at Grant Street Gallery, 216 Grant Street. Ciostek's work documents the area of the West Side she works and lives in (the necklace she wears is a symbol for Sweetness_7 Cafe, where you used to be able to find Viktoria behind the counter on any given day of the week).

Though Ciostek's images point to some of the "discarded" buildings in the neighborhood, Harvey Garrett, executive director of the West Side Community Collaborative will be quick to point out that this is a neighborhood in which the infrastructure is intact, homeowners are invested, and business is beginning to flourish. 

bird.png


Garrett would say that anyone endeavoring to take over any of these structures would find themselves with good neighbors, in a neighborhood that can be brought back from the brink with some vision and work.

Ciostek's artful images then, depending on how they're viewed, can signal discard or opportunity. We spoke to Ciostek about her art and her motivation.



ECB: What came first - your involvement on the West Side or the photo essay?

VC: Well I grew up on the West Side, so it has always been home to me, but both sort of happened simultaneously.  I moved back to Buffalo in October of 2007 after traveling for a few years overseas and then living in Alaska.  When Prish [Moran of Sweetness_7] told me she bought the building, I immediately wanted to be part of the project and moved into the building in April of 2008.  

I was living alone in the building for 6 months before any of the storefronts were open, and though people said I was crazy for living on Grant Street as a woman, I never had a problem.   I loved being in the midst of all the revitalization, I felt like I had this great, perfect, secret home on a frontier that was being pioneered. Those same people that gave me so much grief, who were afraid to even drive down to Grant Street and visit me, now regularly shop at Guercio's and are apartment hunting in the area. 


When I first moved back, I began a project photographing houses on the East side.  When I moved onto Grant Street in the spring, I began walking around my neighborhood and reacquainting myself with the Lower West Side--there my photo projects began focusing on the neighborhoods. 

Viktoria.png

When I was overseas, I spent a lot of time in Greece, Italy, Turkey, Vietnam, India, Laos, and Cambodia, so to be surrounded by a community that was peppered with diversity-Vietnamese, Laotian, African, Puerto Rican, Italian--it just felt so real, so rich, and so much like home.  My family immigrated to the US from Poland when I was just a month old because my father was in the solidarity movement and was forced to leave.  My parents came here with 3 kids, a few suitcases, and hope for a chance at a new life, so when I walk the streets and see how many of the immigrants are forced to live-in poor conditions because of slumlords, poverty, and a mismanaged city that perpetuates the community's decline, well I feel very connected to them.  There is a very enduring quality about the people who live here, and the pride they hold on to.


ECB: You've grown up there, worked there, gone to school there, become familiar with the businesses, community--and you've worked elbow to elbow with the activist/advocates that are working on behalf of the West Side.  Your opinion: on the way up or down, and why?

VC: Definitely up.  There is so much community activism and passion in those who are supporting revitalization projects, it is really heartening to see.  Sweetness_7 Cafe has been a big hub in networking and connecting many people who are involved in the much of the activism, and having worked there, seeing the people and ideas pass through day by day...it's really powerful seeing what people can do when they take things into their own hands.  It's not only in the physical structures, but the mentality of people who are seeing the area more and more for the beauty and potential that it holds.  Civic evolution is not always positive, particularly when a city is run by politicians who don't care about the local citizens, and who continue to disappoint those who depend on them.  Organizations like PUSH, Buffalo ReUse, Grant Ferry Organization, and the Massachusetts Avenue Project are empowering people to take a grassroots approach to rebuilding the quality of life we deserve, to challenge the status quo, and it's really amazing to see.

congress.png

ECB:  What is it you're hoping your audience will see?

VC: I'm hoping my audience will see the cultural value and beauty of these neighborhoods. They are not just grids of streets with dilapidated homes and boarded-up buildings.  They are not worthless communities infested with drugs, gangs, and prostitution.  These are communities rich with culture and these people are worthy of our help.  Most people look at a boarded-up home, its shattered glass, its peeling paint, its overgrown garbage infested lawn, and they see...well, they see a shit hole that needs to be torn down.  I look at the house and wonder why it's in the shape it's in?  What's its story?  Who left it that way, and why?  I also see the potential and beauty in it if someone who cared about it could breath some life back into it.  In a culture where progress and materialism engrave the mentality to constantly throw out the old, buy better and new, to never truly appreciate what we have, to rebuild cheap and temporary, what happens to our values?  We leave fingerprints of our progress on everything we do and touch, but if we truly paid attention to the destruction we left behind, would we continue living the way we do? 


ECB: The houses and buildings you photographed, beyond some artful forms of time worn structures, what's the aura that surrounds them? 

VC: For me, it's the stories they tell through the evidence that's left behind.  When people suffer, the structure of a landscape suffers.  Forgotten structures bridge the past and the present, and they are the lingering clues to human existence where life seems absent.  We all leave fingerprints, and though I choose to never include people in my photographs, essentially it's about the people who impact the area.

zones.png

ECB: Who should see your show?

VC: Everyone.  It's important for every citizen of Buffalo to know what's going on around them, even if it's not where they live.  The west side declined over time through the collective effects of the evolution of our city--we all play a role in that.


Opening reception, 7 to 10PM on the 25th. Show will run until the 2nd week in October.

View image

1 TrackBack

TrackBack URL: http://www.buffalorising.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/4661

464 Gallery owner Marcus Wise opened a show at his Amherst Street gallery last week, entitled "Doors Closed," to open concurrently with the 8th Annual Binational Doors Open Niagara event.The show runs until November 15th and features the works of seven... Read More

Comments

Leave a comment

Grant Street=Buffalo State=incompetent minority (race,gender) tenured political appointment

Need I say more!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Grant St. has been in decline for at least 50 years. Now I may be going out on a limb here but I am guessing white guys were in charge for most of that time.

So Grant St=Buffalo State=incompetent white guy right?

replied to queencity
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Blackrocklifer, you still dont get it though you are only partly correct. Let me explain.

Grant Street really didnt start hitting the skids until the flight for the suburbs in the 1970s, yea that puts it about 40-50 years but it happened all over the westside including Main, Linwood, Delaware, Elmwood, Grant and Niagara. It was Buffalo State students that saved Elmwood and converted much of it to an ever expanding retail and carved up apartment district.

However, here is the gripe...the stabilization of the westside began with Elmwood and expanded outward to Delaware and Richmond and then again to Linwood and past the Richmond barrier but not Grant. By the time Howard came along Elmwood had gentrified beyond the patronage of college crowd.

By the time Howard came along, UB was ramping up its research, ramping up its student body population, planning the Center for Excellence in the Fruit Belt.

Howards mission should have been using its basic sciences and technologies to have matching and complementary programs to UB's research and engineering.

Howards mission should have been expanding its student population, expanding classrooms in its core campus, expanding to Grant and beyond Grant for non-academic facilities (stadiums, offices, parking, dormatories, etc)

Howards mission in expanding Buffalo State would have migrated students from Elmwood which had gentrified beyond the expenses of its college students to Grant/Amherst.

Howards mission should have been to expand the campus with say buildings for a small business incubator similar to UBs on nearby brownfields.

It wasnt likely to happen before Howard because Elmwood was still cheap and unstable enough to need the pennies college kids could provide.

The timing was there for Howards tenure and it was ignored because Howard ignored the surrounding community and she ignored UB and expanding programs and she ignored expanding infrastructure and student population.

The evidence is all there and she was completely incompetent, she insulated herself and punished all faculty that didnt follow her politically correct agenda. Further, she got away with it because she was protected by tenure, gender and race. As a result the westside and blackrock suffered, continued to degrade and lost atleast 20 years.

Today UB and Buffalo State could be partners in technology, partners with UB & BERC in small businesses, Grant could be a unique student strip and Elmwood could be fulfilling its destiny as well...instead...of just starting this transition from Elmwood to Grant.

replied to Blackrocklifer
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Someone should explain to you that:

[a] college and university presidents are *not* tenured;

[b] college and university presidents are *not* political appointments, but are selected through long and exhaustive search processes.

I am confident that others will criticize your consistently racist assumptions, etc.

replied to queencity
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Racists are boring.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Elena, this was a beautiful article and I enjoyed reading about the interesting Ms. Clostek -- I would like to see more -- but, my god, how much Queencity do you expect readers to take? His repetition is on autopilot and his inflammatory schtick takes over article after article. I'm sure he has volumes of pre-written stuff in a Word document that he simply copies-and-pastes here. Do you folks enjoy seeing your articles essentially hijacked day after day? You might as well change the name of BRO to QCB (Queencity blog) because you don't give the readers any choice to avoid his offensive comments.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

As to the hijacking of posts, it bothers me when I think about the pride that people like Viktoria have in their work, only to have a feature about them sullied with hateful, erroneous and repetitive comments. Irks me on their behalf in fact.

I look at a piece like this and think that this young woman would probably like to send a link to everyone she knows, and rightly so - and then there's those comments that take away from it.

All we can do is block a screen name and make it harder for them to post when people are offensive. You must know that we don't ascribe to every reader's beliefs, or to censorship, but in this online community we do our best to keep it polite, salient and sane. And too, it helps when valued commenters, like the ones on this post, push back. Thanks for hanging in there and being right.

replied to PaulBuffalo
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I can sympathize, Elena.

QueenCity, you must be reading so this is to you: whether under your name or any of your former aliases: Look, guy, you're a well intentioned man, we can tell that. But please consider what people feel when they see a diatribe posted by you, particularly one which is only tangentially related to the article at hand. People read the article, form an opinion, get excited about some cogent, intelligent dialogue. Instead, they see a rant (whether by you or someone else) which hardly focuses on the point of the article. It has the effect of taking the wind out of readers' sails. Writers want to focus on one aspect of the post, but the comments seem hell bent on a different discussion. So people walk away instead of steering things back to germane topics.

I share some of your weaknesses/shortcomings. I tend to hog the blog and comment on things outside the scope of the post, steer the discussion to some points other than where the author of the article hoped to lead us. I try to reign it in. I wish you'd try harder, too.

Attracting commentators to articles is a little like trying to sell supermarket customers something at the checkout line: those purchases are impulsive. If readers here see the discussion has been hijacked, they won't bother with the effort of bringing the commentators back on line, they'll simply move on to another article or give up on the blog altogether. You do a disservice to the website by persistently attempting to take the limelight, repeating ad nauseum your bigoted opinions which only marginally (at best) relate to the articles.

Again, I'm no saint in that regard. I should do better myself. But PLEEEEEEEAAAAAAASE!!!!! Not another word about the former Buff State president. I don't know her, I can't judge, and judging by your comments your judgment is seriously suspect. Let it go. UB did no better than Buff State. Buff State did much more for Elmwood than UB has done for Main. You offer Grant Street? I'll trade you Bailey. The college administrations tend to focus on things within their campuses; they see the outside as the city's responsibility. They're at least half right. Move on.

"It is the rare individual who, when weighing the faults of others, does not put his thumbs upon the scale." Remove the log from your own eye before worrying about the sliver in your neighbor's. Howard is gone. Let it go.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Elena, with all due respect, how offensive does one have to be before BRO blocks a screen name? Queencity has had a long run under his current moniker without interruption. In that time, he's invoked Hitler and has been anti-semitic, racist and homophobic. In some of his comments, he's challenged BRO to shut him up.

Of course, BRO can do more to help those of us who simply want to express our displeasure with his comments without having to add a comment and distract from the article at hand: add an 'Agree' and 'Disagree' button within each comment. Many websites include this feature and it allows users to vote thumbs up or thumbs down on someone's comment. Check out the Toronto Globe & Mail's site as just one example.

I certainly don't think that you and BRO endorse every reader's beliefs -- nor should you -- but BRO has not done enough to 'keep it polite, salient and sane'.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Push back comments, well intentioned as they may be, also add clutter so I don't think push back really "helps" much to readers who want to see more substantive comments.

Then there can be push back to the push back, and so on. It's a common issue on blogs. Ignoring is usually the least ineffective response, but some feel ignoring gives the appearance of condoning.

Why not just bring back the Avoid User capability you used to have?

It would take a little bit of coding for your programmers, but then filtering can be easily individualized. Diatribes from you-know-who aren't the only reason some people would use the capability. Some might also find others not worth reading for any reason.

It might also result in more comments because it would be an incetive for more of your "read only" visitors to create a username (and for more people who have a username to log in more often). The more people logged in more often, the more comments you'll get from different people.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Agree with Paul on both counts. Great article.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I second the motion. I am sick of his racism, sexism, and antisemitism day after day.

replied to biniszkiewicz
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Great interview, Elena! But I too am sick of queencity and his boring racists posts. He is an embarassment to this city. I'm sure he chases a lot of sane people away from BRO.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll