City August 4, 2009 4:26 PM

Citizens Take Charge: Judge Nowak Holds Absentee Landlord Accountable

Citizens Take Charge: Judge Nowak Holds Absentee Landlord Accountable

33 acres of blight, an absentee landlord, and a neighborhood struggling to improve.

Today in Judge Henry Nowak's Housing Court, an attorney for Central Park Plaza owner of 25 years Samuel Kurz of Brooklyn, NY, stood in for his client as Nowak discussed the escrow account he wants set up so that all rent revenues go directly to making repairs and improvements on the property.  When the attorney asked if Kurz could pay utilities from the account, Nowak answered, no.  "I expect the money will be in and out quickly for the benefit of the neighborhood," he explained.

This would sound like very good news, except that the enormous parcel is nearly abandoned, with only 8 tenants paying very low rent.  It is a sad case of getting what you pay for, and in the case of the tenants - some paying $500/month or less - a lot of what they get is in the form of a pothole-filled parking lot (unplowed in winter), leaky roofs, and the threat of being menaced in a huge, rambling plaza where all of the light posts have been stripped of copper and wire.

cent park long.JPG

Once a thriving center to the neighborhoods around it, the Central Park Plaza has become a scourge where it sits, with most parents disallowing their children from stepping foot there, and little reason to go there at any rate.  One of the two retail stores left is a beauty supply shop that keeps its door locked between clients, and when clients do enter, they are forced to step around the pans and buckets that catch water from the always leaky roof.  The other is Pee Wee's Variety Store.

cent park peewee.JPG

"Pee Wee" is Robert Brown, who has operated the market for 4 years and says he's on his own when it comes to repairs to the store he rents from Kurz, whether roof leaks, broken windows or running his own electric to the building, which he did.  He says he does his part to stay in the community, holding monthly concerts in the good weather and giving candy to neighborhood children.  But on any given work day, the families and children are scarce.  A few boys on a side street that borders the plaza answered a fast "uh-uh" to the question of whether or not they cross the chain-link line to enter the plaza.

cent park save a lot.JPG

But there is light on the horizon; the neighborhood committee, named Help Revitalize Central Park Plaza (HRCPP) is headed by Beverly Davis (top photo: second from left), and starting last December, she and other members of HRCPP have made more headway than anyone else has been able to accomplish since 2004, when things started to go particularly bad for the parcel.  With the help of Nowak, a Judge typically know for his compassion to residents, while holding negligent landlords' feet to the fire, the community around the plaza is hopeful. 

cent park wilderness.JPG

 

Another coup for the neighborhood is the participation of Michael Macaluso (top photo: right), who has experience with a dramatic neighborhood turn-around.  Macaluso and his wife Judy took possession of Morris Manor a few years back, and once they'd kicked out the prostitutes and drug dealers, they became model landlords. Now the building is an anchor in the community, and a haven for those who live in and around it.  After one unfortunate incident in which a new tenant was followed home and mugged, another tenant mentioned to Macaluso that he had heard something, but didn't look to see what.  Macaluso promptly evicted him for his lack of compassion, saying that everybody needs to look out for everyone else in a real community.

cent park light post.JPG

Beverly Davis reined in Macaluso, and his role in Central Park Plaza will be as court-appointed overseer to the property and tenants.  Today, he told Judge Nowak that he needs the tools to make proper assessments of the damage and necessary repairs.  For a plaza that has scared away most of its tenants and patrons through neglect and blight, the neighbors still hold hope.  They want a grocery store to come back, senior housing, student dorms, a park-and-ride.  "I just want to be able to go there and have a cup of coffee," one woman said.  

cent park store.JPG

And they want a crime camera; one of the buildings that used to house a Mr. 2nd's store is reported to have tow-trucks hauling in cars with no license plates on them, there have been dog fights with carcasses left in the surrounding fields.  All of this has been made known to Councilman Demone Smith, who was present at the courthouse and has a good working relationship with HRCPP.

"This neighborhood could be great," Macaluso said though he believes some would call him crazy for saying so.  "This could be redeveloped all the way to North Fillmore.  It has the potential to be prime property."  Still, he says it needs a lot of discussion, and he needs to know exactly what he has to deal with by getting in and talking to renters. In the meanwhile, Judge Nowak scheduled another court appearance for August 11th at 9:30, and HRCPP is confident that Central Park Plaza will see some changes for the better now that it's on Judge Nowak's docket. 

View image

1 TrackBack

TrackBack URL: http://www.buffalorising.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/4150

Judge Henry Nowak did his part last week to clean up Central Park Plaza by ordering out any entity that wasn't listed on the rent rolls.  That included a female biker club by the name of Bad Habitz, a Paranormal Society that was run by the plaza's... Read More

Comments

Leave a comment

I had to reformat this post and lost the first comments. Will the person who commented about what CPP was like years ago please remind us again? So sorry to lose that.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

well I wasn't that person.. but I did just see this post. I walked to the Central Park Plaza for years as a young child. I grew up just a couple blocks away and a trip to Bells or the Competing Jubilee it was a very different place. It always amazed me that two grocery stores were so close to one another but then again there was a lot less sprawl about.


Murphey's was always a lot of fun. I still remember wandering down each of the isles not knowing what would be around the next corner! The sheer volume of stuff... and the built in diner inside was a great place to pick up a pop.


I also remember the doughnut shop, now can be found on Main Street. The smell is exactly the same.. for those who want the scent of childhood!


Also there was a one photo kiosk over by where Hill street crosses through the plaza. The Payless shoes across the street. The Mr Second building supply, gold dome bank was my first bank account! I didn't even realize how much I remember until I started typing this. Certainly some fun memories.


I used this plaza as a learning ground to riding a bike and roller blades. And I am only 27.. I could only imagine what it was like before me. Probably full of the American Dream of car friendly development... too bad it was the same development that would eventually undermine itself.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

so just spewed my guts and the post gets dropped... lame

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

There was a juke-joint wild time bar in the center of the plaza. Lots of fun to be had on a Friday night route of Slomba's, CPG, Stuffed Mushroom and this bar I can't remember the name of.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Roy I believeof the name of the place was leroys. while at slombas did u cross the street to sylvesters. I work right across from CPP what a mess that place has become. I believe Save Alot left to due to the condition of the building. There are many hard working people in that area who deserve much better. After reading this article I will encourage my co-workers to go to Pee Wees.

replied to Roy
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Too tired, Elena. Basically, up until the 1970s CPP was the northeast Buffalo equivalent to Northtown Plaza, pre-cover Thruway Plaza, or Southgate Plaza; it has Twin Fair, S.S. Kresge, G.C. Murphy, Tops, Western Auto, Super Duper (where I got my first real job in 1983), Loblaws/Bells, and Tops (owned by the Dash's!), along with many other smaller stores. I think there might have been a small movie theater in there at one point, too.

The decline of CPP started in the early 1980s when the area to the south was deep in socioeconomic transition, and Kensington to the east was just beginning to see an exodus of lower middle-class and middle-class residents. Basically, the infamous "east of Main" boundary reached Amherst Street in the early 1980s.

CPP was part of a mixed use development to reclaim the Bennett Quarry site in the 1950s (see http://www.erie.gov/aerials/1951/photos/51_5H112.jpg for a photo from 1951); residential development to the north, and the completion of Amherst Street between Main and Bailey, were part of that project. CPP was a TERRIBLE location for a shopping center, because it's far off the beaten path; it's not on any major or minor arterials. It undermined a business district at Main and Amherst, as well as the Kensington-Bailey business district. It's also a poorly designed plaza - too much parking, no landscaping, no trees, no pervious surface whatsoever. It was never updated from the time it was built, except for the addition of a superficial mansard roof.

IMHO, CPP will _never_ again be a prosperous shopping center. The market isn't there to support a large plaza, it's too far off the eaten path, it'll never draw any customer traffic from those living west of Main, and any business located there is a business that's not on Bailey Avenue, Main Street or Hertel Avenue. Tear it down, recycle the building materials, and landbank it.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Great history lesson Dan.

I agree with the push to remove it and push retail back to main, amherst etc.

How about a story on the old Amherst Lanes? That place is huge. I've only check out the empty shell. The lanes on the second floor looked cool. VIP feature?

replied to Dan
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Thanks so much, Dan.

replied to Dan
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

What else did I say ... okay, I know I'm getting nostalgic for Central Park Plaza. Since it seems like all the old farts in Buffalo bawl their eyes out at the mere mention of Sattlers or "998", let me feel some nostalgia for a dumpy, ill-placed plaza. We children of the 1970s were the first generation to live in a Buffalo that was on a constant decline, so there's not as much to be nostalgic for.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I don't remember much about the plaza other than my grandmother used to drive from Genesee/Bailey to get buy yard in one of the stores- was there a D&K there?

Anyway- I'm with Dan- retail isn't going to work here. Good idea about landbanking- light commercial may work as well.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Other area memories:

* TheREALsbrof, there was a Fotomat by Western Auto.

* The neighborhood north of Amherst Street and east of Main was VERY nice.

* Lots of retirees living in the apartments on Amherst Street, and the townhouses on Bennett Village Terrace.

* Tons of gypsy cabs would line up in front of Super Duper, waiting for elderly, carless customers. Their drivers would entice passengers by shouting "CAAAAAAAAAAA SERRRRRVICE!", "LIBBUHREE", and "HAAAAAAAAAAAACK!" One shouted "HEBUHDAH!"; I had no idea what that was about.

* A woman shopping at Super Duper complained to me that there were too many white kids working there, and that from now on she was going to do all her shopping at Figmo's. She asked me where the "little baby Jesuses" were, and I had no idea what they were. Another women threatened me with a beating by "The Man" if I swept too close to her. "The Man" was a man accompanying her that looked like a combination of Shaft and Mohammad Ali. Strange place to work.

* One of the area's best thrift stores in the 1980s was in CPP; a big Amvets.

* Items at Kresge's were market with tags that read "KEY 5", "KEY 9" and the like. I have no idea what that meant.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This plaza is poorly located and more than tired.

CPP should be demolished and the 33 acres should be transformed into a new city park. Push what little retail remains out to Main Street. Build basketball courts (those at Delaware Park are often full), picnic areas, baseball diamonds, open meadow, perhaps even a pool. A park would give a shot in the arm to the surrounding housing.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

WCPerspective> was there a D&K there?

There was a D&K up on Bailey Avenue by Amherst Street.

Yeah, I'm getting old. GET OFF MY LAWN!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

About a year ago, Wendel Duchscherer led some community brainstorming sessions to envision a possible future for the Central Park Plaza. Among the suggestions was a nine hole golf course. Retail would be promoted along Main Street and Fillmore Avenue. This option would add value to the neighborhood housing stock and allow for rehab and infill.

A plan such as this could easily add connections to Delaware Park and create a greenway connecting Gleasner (Manhattan) Playground, McCarthy Park, Shoshone Park and the proposed Greenway from LaSalle Transit station to Tonawanda and eventually all the way to Niagara Falls. Federal money has been available for this for five years.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I love the golf course idea. I'd love to see the course in Delaware Park removed. This could replace that. Delaware Park could be returned to public use as a meadow (Olmsted's design) as opposed to a public golf course (available only to golfers).

What kind of federal money?

replied to peripatetic
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

As a active member of the HRCPP committee we ask that if anyone has any suggestions or ideas for the Plaza please come to our meeting, it is scheduled for next Wednesday, August 12, 2009 @ F.L.A.R.E. Center, 307 Leroy St, Buffalo, NY at 5:30 p.m. everyone is welcome to attend.

This committee has been together for a short time and in that time we feel that we have brought notice to an isore in the city, although it will take time to have the immediate Plaza area redeveloped we're just looking for all input from everyone. Keep in mind there are several parks around with basketball courts as mentioned in another post, and 9 hole course is a great idea however we need to be realistic. This committee is not hoping for the CPP of old in it's hey day with all the retail shopping, etc. Yes 'some' retail would be nice but we know it will never be that so please come out to the meeting and voice your opinion, and your concerns.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It is about time something was done about the vacant, deteriorating Central Park Plaza. That place is a terrible disgrace and a hangout for vagrants and drug dealers. The #32 Amherst Street bus used to go through Central Park Plaza but that service was discontinued a few years ago because nobody got on or off the bus at that already largely vacant shopping center. It is time to get tough on slumlords by fining them and even throwing them into jail for property negligence. It is time to pursue all the other slumlords as well especially on the east side and lower west side.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I see a Save-A-Lot store on Google; is that gone already?

Best plan for this spot: tear down, rip up, plow the ground, plant a bunch of oaks, maples, berry bushes, fence it off, and leave it for the birds.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

i have given up hope on seeing IKEA take the place of the mythical Bass Pro downtown so my new hope is to see it come to life in the Central Park Plaza. IKEA has done good things with a marginal neighborhood in Brooklyn...why not here? An IKEA would be great for jobs and would not crush locally owned businesses they way Wal Mart does.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

What a great piece of land it would be for some future use.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

$1.2 million in Congestion Air Quality Mitigation funds were awarded Buffalo to build a bikeway / greenway from Main Street (LaSalle station) to Kenmore Avenue and Starin Avenue. Another $1.4 million went to Tonawanda for the section from Kenmore Avenue north. A couple hundred thousand has been spent by Buffalo for planning.

Meanwhile in today’s News “The Federal Home Loan Bank of New York awarded $70,000 for another First Niagara-backed project, the construction of the Jewett Avenue Apartments by Fillmore-Leroy Area Residents, or FLARE, to support development of eight units of affordable housing.”
Where is this comprehensive / non scatter site housing plan?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

An update to the court proceedings for CPP. Judge Nowak has placed Central Park Plaza into a receivership, and has named Michael Macaluso manager. This means the owner is no longer in the picture however, he will have to pay all the bills. He will not receive any rents from anyone. That money will be used to begin the process of cleaning and fixing up everything which is broken as well as attempting to bring in new tenants. Thank you Elena and Buffalo Rising for your care and concern. We are finally hopeful as to what can happen in that expanse of land. Beverly Davis

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment