City May 5, 2009 7:50 AM

Reminder to VOTE: School Board Elections Today

Reminder to VOTE: School Board Elections Today

Buffalo School Board elections take place today, and both the Buffalo Niagara Partnership and Grassroots Buffalo (a decades-old, predominantly African American coalition) have come out in favor of the same 3 at large school board incumbents: Dr. Catherine Collins, Florence Johnson and Christopher Jacobs.

In an election that has a typically low voter turnout--less than 5 percent of registered voters--many a school board race is decided by very small margins, sometimes far less than 100 votes.

The Partnership's choice of candidates, according to President and CEO Andrew Rudnik, "are the best qualified to manage the schools' $600+ million budget, will stand up in favor of reform in the system and are not beholden to the efforts of Buffalo Teacher Federation President Philip Rumore -- which for too long have obstructed the change that is in the best interest of Buffalo's school children."

While the Partnership's endorsement hinges largely on the ability to improve graduation rates, thus keeping more students in school and creating a pool of viable candidates for the region's workforce, Grassroots is concentrating more on the Three Year Academic Achievement Plan already put in place that they would like to see carried forward with no interruption in administration.

Grassroots Buffalo gave high marks to the same 3 candidates, and put forth a statement saying, " Several candidates rose above the others who were interviewed and displayed a clear understanding and dedication to the School District's Three-Year Academic Achievement Plan, encouraging and utilizing professional development for the staff, extended time on task, enhanced use of literacy across the curriculum, and implementing the use of proven academic tools and resources such as Harcourt Trophies, Voyager Passport and Direct Instruction.

A change in the school board now, according to Peter Simon of The Buffalo News could mean an early end to Superintendent Dr. James Williams' tenure in Buffalo, and both the Partnership and Grassroots believes that an interruption at this time would spell trouble for plans put in place by Williams that they say have already shown "steady progress and success."

In making its endorsements, The Partnership outlined the following targeted data that they believe Williams, with the support of Collins, Johnson and Jacobs, is most likely to have an impact on:

1). Buffalo is our region's core  -- and the success or failure of the Buffalo Public Schools is directly linked to how the city fares. Currently:

·      Buffalo is the nation's third-poorest city, according to the U.S. Census.

·       The Buffalo metro area has the highest black male jobless rate (51.4 percent) among American's 35 large cities, according to figures cited by Professor Marc V. Levine of the University of Wisconsin-Milwaukee.

·       Nearly two-thirds of adults in Buffalo function at the two lowest levels of literacy, meaning they can't function at the minimum level of literacy employers in our region require for any job higher than entry level.

·      Thirty-five percent of Buffalo Public School children don't graduate high school.

2). At a time when many students are not graduating from high school prepared for postsecondary education and work, 60 percent of the new jobs being created require advanced training or a college education. If our region's workforce can't meet employer needs, we will lose existing companies, and will not be able to recruit new businesses to invest in our region.

3). The availability of high-quality human talent is a top issue facing businesses today. Nationwide, business leaders increasingly place improving public education at the top of their list of priorities because they believe the education system in the United States fails to produce graduates prepared to compete both locally and in a global economy.

View image

1 TrackBack

TrackBack URL: http://www.buffalorising.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/1500

The Buffalo Public Schools - and the Buffalo Board of Education in particular - have been the center of debate for years.  Despite the critical role the public school system plays in Buffalo's long-term health, voter turnout for school board elect... Read More

Comments

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising is endorsing?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Full disclosure would be nice here. George Johnson, Buffalo Rising co-founder, is the son of incumbent BOE member Florence Johnson.

The fact that the names of the challengers aren't even included is incredibly disappointing. In addition, some discussion of the fact that there is an active investigation taking place (in court yesterday) regarding the funding of the three incumbents by the partnership would have given at least an illusion of full coverage of the story. See Artvoice online or Rich Newberg's story last night on WIVB for more on that.

The challengers running against the three incumbents are:

Rosalind Hampton (a nurse with grandchildren in the BPS)
John Licata (an attorney with 4 kids at Olmsted and City Honors)
Byron McIntyre (Buffalo firefighter with kids in the BPS)
Rebekah Williams (works for Community Foundation with a son in the BPS)
Patricia Devis (chemistry professor at ECC)

Hampton, Licata, and McIntyre are running together as a 'students first' coalition are are aligned with board members who are trying to stand up to Williams' failed policies and climate of intimidation and vindictiveness.

Really, really disappointing post, BR.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The Phil Fairbanks link contains as much information about some of the challengers as this post does about the incumbents.

George Johnson is undertaking a new project in New York and San Francisco, and is as far removed form BRO as he could possibly be with the exception of reading the site now and then, for which we have no proof.

This is not an endorsement, but it is a statement about the Partnership's views, along with those of Grassroots. Depending on how you feel about either of those organizations, this could go either way.

replied to Eissien
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Yeah, this is pretty lame. If BRO is going to be a stenographer for the Partnership, at least be honest about it and call this an endorsement rather than pretending it's just another article.


For an alternate view on the election, see http://eagercolin.wordpress.com/2009/05/04/46/


Shameless.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Rest assured that BRO's intent was simply to get more than 5 percent of the population out to vote. Regardless of the perceived slant of this post by any given reader, we hope it will push people to go pull a lever.

We tend to fall in the category of thinking that something as important as education in this town needs to be voted on by people outside of the families and friends of the candidates.

replied to Colin
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Seems to me that if all you wanted to do was get people to go out and vote you should have simply said what you said in your comment, "We tend to fall in the category of thinking that something as important as education in this town needs to be voted on by people outside of the families and friends of the candidates."


And then if you wanted to encourage people and help them make an informed decision you could have simply listed all the canididates their background and maybe what their goals for the BOE are or just link to those Q's Chris provided. Seems alot simpler than letting us all know who the Partnership prefers. If you really wanted to get crazy you could have profiled all the candidates leading up to today. You know, do interviews, and "journalist" kinda stuff.


The only place you encourage people to vote is in the title. I have to agree, it looks like an endorsement. If you really thought it was important you would have devoted alot more effort to covering it instead of covering chow chocolat, awnings, and the Bandits and not just slapped up the partnerships picks as people head off to the polls.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Editorially, the article announces that someone as big as the BNP endorses the incumbents. That's news.

Supported by a message to vote, we saw that as being fit (and interesting enough) to put up, especially with a link to Simon.

replied to EasySon
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Take it easy on Elena, she thinks that we are all morons who cannot think for ourselves. How many more years does she want to give to the two incumbents who have been on the board for years? I like to think that with Johnson and Collins, there should be little children who started kindergarten in their system and end up graduating (?) 13 years later under their tenure and still not know how to do the basics of reading and writing. The joke is that Johnson and Collins will still be preaching accountability and improvement. How many more years of improvement is needed until children can pass minimum standards?

Not voting is not an option.

replied to EasySon
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wow, that's a little harsh. I am neither friends nor family with anyone running. I do, however, have two young children who are exposed on a daily basis to these so-called "proven" methods of direct instruction (teachers reading scripts from binders) and "fidelity" to the Harcourt series.


Elena's comment is especially ironic when the connection (albeit geographically distant now) between one of the BRO founders and an incumbent candidate named in the article was not disclosed.


If you're truly interested in the democratic process, please begin by providing both sides of the issue.


A good place to start is the Coalition for Economic Justice's School Board Voter's Guide. You can get to it by following Colin's link above or by going to their website.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Eissien,

I'm not saying you're related, just that the numbers are almost low enough to suggest very little of the population--who isn't friend or family of a candidate--tends to vote for school board. The polls need you and thousands more like you, just to start. Many thousands for something as important as public education.

The Coalition for Economic Justice is as union as you can get in this town. Just sayin'.

replied to Eissien
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'm not interested in the particular political slant of the staff of BRo or the supposed "connections" to and between Chris Jacobs, BNP, etc. All seems kinda silly. A more germane question would be. how many people who work for BRO send their kids to Buffalo Public Schools?




Elena, are your kids in public schools?




Did Newell attend Buffalo Public Schools?




Just wondering. It might be anecdotal, but I find that many of the City's leading evangelists send their kids to private schools, which seems a bit disingenuous. A personal investment in the public schools from such forward thinking people would probably be a net benefit to the system.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Chris,

I'm always amazed by your "calling out". Try this little bit of reality on for size - a lot of people who would like to see improvement in the Buffalo Public Schools have their children in private school because (drumroll) the Buffalo Public Schools (are you ready) need improvement.

If you're asking for my opinion as an individual, I think the schools are on the upswing, but that comes too late for my high school and college aged children.

And your assertion that yours is a germane question in the first place is odd, as I am the only person on staff with children in school. Add to that the fact that we are named "Buffalo Rising" not "Buffalo, Home of the Best Public School System" and I see no conflict here.

Asking people to vote simply becomes a way to evoke successful solutions through community involvement (a function of BRO). That, by the way, is why I've lent all the time I could, and pulled every string I had in town to do my part for tomorrow's Dropout Prevention Summit. But by your way of thinking, you, Chris, might see this as my being a false figure because none of my children have dropped out of school.

Sometimes, in lieu of a flawed argument, I wish you would state the basis for your emotional conflict with BRO.

replied to Chris Smith
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

how could where BR staffers children attend school be at all relevant to who should be elected to the School Board? Are you serious?

You're like the silly Washington partisans who derided Clinton's and Obama's education policy initiatives because they sent their daughters to Sidwell Friends.

Everyone knows - and admits - the Buffalo public schools are in bad shape and need to improve. Wealthy people who live in the city know this too and since they have the means to give their kids a better shot at a quality education, they often opt to send their kids to private schools. This somehow disqualifies them from having an opinion on the school board and who should be on it? Or disqualifies them from having good ideas altogether? It's a moronic suggestion, and even though Chrisa is haunting this site, it may be the dumbest comment of the day/week/year.


replied to Chris Smith
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I concur. I'm sure there are plenty of people who would prefer sending their kids to public school as opposed to dropping 10k+ a year sending them to private school. I'm also sure that a huge percentage of people who love the city but ended up moving to the suburbs, did so because they didnt want to send their kid to public schools in the city, where half the kids can barely read and dont even graduate. I currently do not have children, but in the coming years i'm sure i will be faced with the decision to send my kid to buffalo private school, buffalo public school, or eek, move to the burbs for the sake of a quality education that isnt going to cost 10+k per year. I can tell you 100% that if the public schools in the city dont greatly improve, that wont even be a option that will even be considered.
-
I'm pretty sure I speak for a great majority of people who are my age, and live in the city, and will be having children in the future. According to the last two BRO demographic based reader polls, 50% live in the city, and the vast majority of readers are in my age group, so unless the public school do in fact become anything but a joke, the city will continue to lose population, and/or the private school will continue to do well, very well.

replied to Cardiff Giant
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Elena, whether or not the Coalition for Economic Justice is "as union as you can get in this town" is not really applicable to the discussion. The questions they asked of the candidates were not union specific. Here they are:

1. Why are you the best candidate for the position?

2. If you are elected or re-elected, what are the top three priorities for you? How would you suggest approaching these issues?

3. Do you have children in the Buffalo Public Schools?

4. What measures do you think the Board of Education should take to close the forecasted budget gap?

5. Do you see any connections between the condition of our neighborhoods and the quality of our schools?

6. How would you vote on the passage of a Living Wage policy that covers both direct employees and contracted employees? Why?

7. What new ideas will you put on the table during your term?

8. Are you open to working in collaboration with parents, students, and issue based community groups? What do you see as the benefit to this?

9. What responsibilities, if any, should the Buffalo Public District, assume for dealing with societal problems such as poverty, hunger, emotional illness and drug abuse?

I think these are all decent questions and the responses given by the candidates (except for Florence Johnson who didn't respond) are informative and give some insight into their qualifications and plans.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

BR isn't obligated to provide both sides of anything. Whether or not they call it an endorsement, it reads very much like one. Why they don't just call it an endorsement seems silly, and denying it so strongly borders on insulting reader intelligence.

However, can't a similar critique be made of Artvoice? They've been doing very good coverage lately of city politics and the school board, but they're often very slanted and clearly they oppose the three incumbents (just as clearly as BR is supporting them). Yet Artvoice doesn't use the "endorsement" word either. (Or do they? If they did, I didn't see it.) Colin, is Artvoice being shameless too?
-
I could still change my mind, but I'm leaning toward not voting this time. I don't want to vote for the incumbents because I think Williams should be fired, but what I've read about the challengers sounds bad too. I think their control of the board would very possibly harm quality even more than keeping the incumbents would. So if I'm an example, all of the non-voting isn't due to apathy. Some of it is due to strong opposition to both factions.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Who am I "calling out"? I just asked a question. I am being quite serious that the Buffalo Schools would be better off if more people put their kids in the schools and worked to improve those schools as active members of the school community. Do you disagree with that assessment?




I take it from your hyper-defensive comment that your children are not students in the Buffalo Schools. I have no idea why you can't have a conversation without immediately thinking we're out to get you, it's quite tiring.




Offering support and feedback to the local teaching staff as involved parents and providing input into the school board processes is an important part of life wherever one chooses to live.




To Cardiff Giant, I think comparing Elena Buscarino to Bill Clinton or Barack Obama is just plain silly. Totally different situations, unless, of course Elena's kids also need 24/7 supervision from the Secret Service.




I simply made an observation that wealthy people in the city generally choose to send their kids to private schools. It's germane to the discussion because this site is about Buffalo "Rising" and quality education is a cornerstone to that ever happening. Pulling kids out of the schools is an explicit statement of distrust in the system itself, just as explicit a statement that tens of thousands of people have made in the last several years to flee the city for suburban schools. If you don't see how any of the above is germane to THIS post being on THIS website, well, I don't really know what to tell ya.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Nice try, but it really isn't germane at all. And you clearly know it as anyone can tell with your tortured logic.

But let's say it does somehow matter - do you have kids? Do they go to Buffalo public schools? Do you live in the city? If not, by your logic, shouldn't your opinion be immediately dismissed?

replied to Chris Smith
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

PS: The more the community gets involved, the more schools will improve. The more schools improve, the more graduates we'll have. With more graduates, we'll have a community full of assets rather than liabilities. Buffalo will rise.

Bottom line: Get involved and vote.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Food Fight!!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Actually, my kids are not germane to the issue because I didn't post an article on my website telling people how to vote in an election that doesn't apply to me.




My logic is not tortured in the slightest, unless you are bending over backwards to defend Elena from the horrific prospect of a reader asking a question about an article posted on her website.




Perhaps Cardiff can head over to defend Elena's honor at Artvoice.com next, they have something to say about all of this as well.




http://blogs.artvoice.com/avdaily/2009/05/05/partnership-barks-buffalo-rising-jumps/

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

To easyson's point:




If you really thought it was important you would have devoted alot more effort to covering it instead of covering chow chocolat, awnings, and the Bandits and not just slapped up the partnerships picks as people head off to the polls.




I think if you used the search function, you'd see that BR posted a couple of articles leading up to the election. They provided as much coverage as would be expected.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I'm aware of the articles. Upon searching again I found only one dedicated article to the forum, a mention and link in a WBFO story and then the dropout story. Not much more than that although I will admit I thought there were one or two more dedicated articles in there somewhere.

The forum article is actually very good. I'm not questioning the coverage. And everything Elena is saying now is also very good and should have been in the article. But judging from Elena's comments this is an issue she believes is important and all I'm saying is that if she and BRO believe it is maybe they should have covered it more. perhaps they could have done a profile of each candidate. That would have been helpful no? And while there are all sorts of links in the stories the only en


To Elena's point:

your article may announce BNP's backing of particular candidates but your headline is "Reminder to VOTE..." If your intent was to report the news that the Partnership endorses certain candidates then why not have the headline reflect the articles content? Seems simple to me. Outside of the headline of the article where in the body does it remind anyone to vote? Where is the information about hours and polling places, etc.? All I'm saying is that from a readers perspective it sounds like an endorsement.

replied to Chris Smith
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Does anybody happen to know if there's anything posted online about how the candidates stand on the issue of adding more charter schools?

I haven't seen that anywhere, so I'm guessing all of the candidates oppose more charters. Williams has spoken out against charters recently, and the BTF opposes them too.

I'd probably vote for any qualified candidate who favors firing Williams for his incompetence and who also advocates for adding more charter schools, but I haven't heard of any such candidate running.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Chris - you've referenced the buffalo public schools in stuff you posted to your site so does that make your kids germane? or where you live? or whatever other nonsensical personal point you'd like to choose - say religion, or height, or weight?

http://buffalogeek.wnymedia.net/blogs/2007/09/30/its-about-a-city/

Or because you didn't encourage people to vote in the school board elections do you still get to avoid the pointless question you posed to others? When you simply try to contrive rules for when personal actions are relevant to public postings, it's hard for me to follow along so forgive the questions.

Also, I'd head over to Artvoice to read their view on this topic but I have a feeling I already know the answer - they oppose everyone and everything except "massage parlors" where various photoshopped Asian women will give me a happy ending for a very reasonable price.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

There's a sucker born every minute.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The problem is stupid people.

-Lazy stupid teachers and the unions that protect them

-Lazy stupid parents and the political correctness and welfare state that protects them

-Lazy citizens who spend more time leaving stupid comments on BRO than getting their friends and neighbors out to vote for who'll represent them on a board directly effecting one of the most important issues facing the city.

The city will never attract the jobs it needs until it fixes its public education system and stops treating it as a lottery for ****ty teachers and a babysitting service for parents who, in any sane world, would have been sterilized at the age of 13.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

1. My "shameless" wasn't in reference to Elena or BRO. It was in reference to myself, and the shameless plug for my blog Will There Ever Be a Rainbow? I still have no shame: http://eagercolin.wordpress.com/2009/05/04/46/


2. That said, it seems a bit disingenuous to reprint a press release from one side in an election and claim it's an effort at getting people to vote.


3. Rebekah Williams is in favor of charter schools. See http://www.facebook.com/event.php?eid=102030390350

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Yeah, a GOTV claim doesn't add up. EasySon makes a good point that candidate profiles over the past week would have helped publicize the election if that was the true intent. They have no obligation to do that, of course, but to not do it then at the last minute publish a pro-Williams post claiming it's just for GOTV... nope, not many people will believe that. I don't get it why they just don't endorse the 3 incumbents, and I equally don't get it why Artvoice didn't directly say they oppose the 3 incumbents. There's nothing wrong with taking a stand.

replied to Colin
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I just read some Rebekah Williams info http://rebekahwilliams.org/on_issues
and looked again at her answers to the coalition. I don't agree with everything she says, but some of it isn't awful. Among challengers, she sounds best. Her web site's pro-charter statement probably cost her the BTF endorsement.
Looking at the incumbents' answers, Jacobs sounds much better than Catherine Collins, and Florence Johnson wouldn't even answer.
-
So I'll vote for Williams and Jacobs, the least objectionable each of the newcomers and incumbents. None of the others sounds deserving of using my third vote. Unfortunately for Williams and Jacobs, me voting for them will likely jinx their chances. Oh well.

replied to Colin
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Ok... To really beat you over the head with my point...

In the last 24 hours there have been two posts about Cinco De Mayo and one about the ever so important election. Two events on the same day, Cinco De Mayo and an election, and Cinco De Mayo gets more coverage...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

same-old,

Ever hear of the fundamental attribution error? Check it out: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fundamental_attribution_error

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Colin, you make my point.

You respond by pointing to a Wikipedia page (alone, kind of retarded) that begins explaining fundamental attribution error: "There is no universally-accepted explanation for the fundamental attribution error".

Which failing Buffalo Public School did you graduate from?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Whether anyone has kids in Buffalo's public schools or not, it is everyone's business. Without waxing poetic or getting too philosophical about the issue, we are all stakeholders as we will all be affected by the outcomes of our nation's youth. Today's dropout just might be the nurse's assistant who administers your care in old age for example. Dropout rates are on the rise all over the nation. All the clamor over raising the bar in public schools led to No Child Left Behind. So, up went the bar. Up, also, went the dropout rate. That is a discussion for another forum, but I will suffice it to say that the very kids it was intended to help ended up being the ones who were left even further behind. As NCLB is an unfunded federal mandate, local districts and boards have no choice but to comply.

There is a direct correlation between poverty and rates. Affluent school districts have high graduation rates. It's all very simple.

The job of Boards is to make policy, enforce policies, and ensure that the district is fiscally sound. It is crucial that people of the highest quality be elected to these positions.

It is a unfortunate that school board selections are not held in conjunction with November elections. But, as long as Americans believe that all citizens are not stakeholders in public education, this will not change.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Freaking Hilarious that Chris Smith wants to call out the BRO staff for where they went to school or send their kids to school. Even funnier is a guy from WNYmedia saying both sides should be discussed on a blog.

While the Buffalo Public Schools would be better off if every community minded person sent their kids to public schools...but those children would not be. Who the hell gives anyone the right to get on a soap box and suggest someone should sacrifice their kids education for the greater benefit of the public.

Going along the same line...just how many kids of Buffalo Public School teachers GO TO BUFFALO PUBLIC SCHOOLS? How many teachers who collect a paycheck from the city actually live in the city so they can send their kids to Buffalo Public Schools? We all know the answers.

Any parent worth a salt does not mess with their child's education. PERIOD. END OF STORY.

The problem is because of the f*cked up liberal, grow the Democratic party via Social Service enrollment mentality of New York State...their are plenty of parents in the City of Buffalo not worth a salt.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment