Regional April 19, 2009 9:20 AM

Politics

Politics
The other day, a friend told me about a very interesting and promising deal he is negotiating with a major entity in Buffalo.  (I'll keep the project and the friend's identity under wraps for now, not wanting to speak too soon.)

The point here is that this friend spoke to someone who works in a major regional political office, and asked if perhaps their boss would care to sign on to the project.  The answer was, "If it goes through, call us.  We'll be there for the signing."

My friend explained that the signing would be more likely if there was some more political weight behind it.  What was being looked for was support on this side of the project, not a bigger crowd for the photo-op should the signing go through.  It was disappointing to my friend to say the least; the unspoken answer being, "We won't help, but we'll put our face on it at the end so we can take some credit."

It sparked a memory of a lesson I'd learned long ago in a children's book--one that has applied to life over and over, in different circumstances, ever since.  I immediately went to Talking Leaves and picked up a copy of The Little Red Hen.

red hen group.jpg
For those of you who aren't familiar, the hen in the story is literally scratching for dinner for her children, when she comes upon some seeds.  The pig, dog, goat and rat all tell her what she needs to do with the seeds, but when asked to help, they all answer "Not I" to the various chores that need doing.  

red hen not I.jpg
Though each of the other animals have specialized talents that would help the hen greatly through the process from seed to bread, they won't help plant, harvest or carry the grain to the mill.  Once she lugs her grain to the mill herself, the kind miller (who is quite human) not only grinds it, but gives the little hen a jar of jam to boot.  

red hen miller.jpg
Back home, neither the dog, goat, pig nor rat are willing to help with the baking either, all answering, "Not I" to the hen's final plea for help.

red hen yard.jpg
However, when the bread is baked, and it's time for the photo op...er...meal, everyone is available.  The hen, with the sun (who looks a lot like the miller) looking on, points her little red wing at the loafers and reminds them how they contributed nothing to the greater good of the community...uh...baking the bread, and then she feeds her family warm bread and benevolent jam.  The end.

red hen end.jpg
The Little Red Hen book should be read and taken to heart by every man, woman and child, and it wouldn't hurt to have a copy handy at swearing in ceremonies.  Everybody, smile for the camera!
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

I love this - nomination for article of the month, anyone--?


I've noticed in many of the community projects I've been involved in - and even led - we worked hundreds of hours and even gave hundreds of dollars of our own resources (and sometimes even more in opportunity costs), sometimes with very little (or no) visible support from politicians -- and in some cases, had them put roadblocks or hurdles in our path. Yet when it comes time for the press conference or ribbon cutting, there they are crowing - like a rooster at dawn taking credit for the sun coming up. Which makes me wonder BTW why they didn't fit a rooster into the Little Red Hen story somewhere...


Disappointing, yes, but a maturing reality to recognize and deal with. Politicians want to be associated with things that are successful. End of story. Sometimes a group has to do something, show progress, be successful, and invite the politicians out to the ribbon cutting whether they helped or not, turning a blind eye to the credit-claiming and bandwagonning. Often, that helps get buy-in from the politicians, and if the group or initiative can keep up the momentum, the politicians may step up to the plate and provide some real help with the next project or phase.


So the cold reality for all of us Little Red Hens is that sometimes it takes moving forward on something that needs to happen, or needs to be done, without knowing whether anyone political will ever get on board. That can mean lots of time, energy, and sweat equity, without always a guarantee of success or payoff. Sometimes you just have to have faith that a "friendly miller" will be there to help out at a critical moment, or with a critical piece -- and sometimes that friendly miller is indeed a progressive or thoughtful politician. They are out there - there are several in Buffalo who I'd be honored to have representing me - and should be celebrated and supported. So while it's not fair to tar them all with the same brush, the best outlook when approaching politicians for support is to have very realistic and open-eyed expectations - yet being open to being pleasantly surprised.


Politicians will tell you, as well, that the shoe is often on the other foot. There are times when they need support - especially early on in their careers when they don't have a track record of accomplishment yet - and feel very much the Little Red Hen. Who will go with me to walk a neighborhood--? Who will come to a campaign rally and bring a friend--? Who will host a meeting in their home with some of their friends and neighbors--? "Not I" (or "I'll get back to you") is so often what they hear - yet after they're elected the same people show up and want favors.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Makes you wonder why we even need government involvement at all.

replied to RaChaCha
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Perhaps the goat, dog, and pig were unskilled or unable to plant and harvest the seeds. Perhaps they didn't have means to bring the seed to the miller and even if they did maybe they couldn't pay him to grind it. The wealthy hen who has the means also gets a free gift from the miller because she has given him her business, sound familiar? The dog, pig, and goat, do not have grain or bread so they cannot get the free jam, but look at the actions of the hen who believe that she deserves the free jam. No, she not only deserves it, but she feels that she has earned it and can hoard it for her family and keep it from the community.


The Hen is only concerned about herself and her output, she isn't concerned with the fact that the dog protects the farm and the hens from predators, she is only concerned about what she made for herself and her family. She incorrectly assumes that she is the only one working and that the others are inherently lazy, so therefore they are not as deserving of the wealth. Instead of helping the community, she looks out for herself and family only. Benevolent jam indeed, it is her greed that provided her the unique opportunity to get the jam from the miller, who could have shared it with the community as well. No, the greedy help the greedy and the rest suffer under false assumptions of laziness. Sounds all too familiar to me.

Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Nice description of Communism, Heather... Put down the individual that tries to work hard and get things done, and make endless excuses for the others that sit around and want things handed to them. Egad.

replied to Heather
Score: 1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wow on this one, too. Reads like Timothy Leary.

replied to Heather
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

WOW! Nice one, Elena!

Have seen this happen over and over again through various levels of government.

"Hey, let's work together and help them out!" at a press conference and then - silence........deafening. And, in the interim, others ask what has happened to the previously verbose and supposed benefactors. So, we dig in and keep working with our resources, no matter how small.

On the other hand we had a situation here where someone really did their part, didn't even notify us it was a done deal, started the work, and didn't ask for a press conference. We held one, anyway. In order to continue with the basis of this story, we won't let on as to who he/she/they was/were. He/she/they know.

Unfortunately, the doers/hens have a great deal on their collective plates. But, they keep on doing.

Tnanks for a great analogy.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

So basically Heather, you want Miss Hen to do all the work, and the rest to not help, even when asked, and then her provide them food when they wouldn't help in production, even though they had specialized skills to help in the process. I thought the commune utilized each person's work to achieve a singular goal, but instead you're backing the laziness of those others to benefit from the one animal that worked. I can't blame you though as I'm sure Animal Farm is your favorite farm animal book.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

So basically Nick, Miss Hen may have done work by planting the seeds and harvesting the wheat, but she does not take into account the contribution of the dog who provides her and the other animals the protection from predators that is necessary for her to grow her crop. She doesn't acknowledge the roles that the pig and goat play on the farm either, because she is only concerned about herself. She is working to take care of herself and her family, all others must do as she says or they cannot share in the benefits of the crop. You are a lot like Miss Hen, when you automatically assume that because the other animals are lazy because they are not participating in that one function. The god may not be as highly regarded by the miller for the work that he performs, but don't assume that he is lazy as a result, maybe the dog's feet are not built to scratch the ground to plant seeds like the hen's feet are. In the same vein, maybe the hen doesn't have the acute sense of smell and sight that the dog has, so she wouldn't be good at protecting the farm. If we extend this story out a little, we will see the dog starve due to lack of food because the greedy hen though that the dog was lazy. The dog might die from starvation, leaving the farm unprotected the following year, which makes it impossible for Miss Hen to grow more wheat, and she and her family starve just a little while later. Granted, the Hen family was living better and felt that they were doing it all, but when the basics start to go, they aren't too far behind. I wonder who Miss Hen will blame when her family goes hungry the following year. Do you think the miller will still give her the benevolent jam when she has no grain to mill? What will happen to the miller's family when Miss Hen and others are unable to grow grain to grind?


It takes the entire community to survive, the system of individual contribution for individual gain is flawed and doomed to collapse. Open your eyes and look around and you will see signs of that everywhere.

replied to nick
Score: -1 ( 1 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

People aren't animals. People have responsibilities to one another that don't exist between animals. People live in man-made economic environments that are not of their choosing, and which are often hostile to their survival. Animals live in nature.


The analogy isn't apt.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Heather- I surrender (nice rhyme...) - you won - you play the devils advocate absolutely brilliantly-but makes me wonder what kind of fairy tales you read for your little ones?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Barnyard critters are often used to depict the humanities to children. "Humanities" refers to the "quality or state of being human".
.
As far as being able to make the intellectual leap from animals to humans:
.
Kiddies get it.
.
Adults reading children's stories to children not only get it but also get it that children get it.
.
Another kind of creature though, in particular a leech depicting a human; leeches do not get it.
.
(Yes, I know that actual leeches have value to humans by being medically beneficial and I also know that fishermen and fisherwomen as well as fishes love leeches too.)
.
As far as a rooster characterization goes, (my not knowing if any are ever used to depict family life in stores for children), but if they were, roosters in children's stories could easily represent human deadbeat dads.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Crisa - Seriously, what was that? You are either on drugs or they decided to put a computer in the Bristol Home. Which is it?

replied to Crisa
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If Elena's complaint about politicians showing up for ribbon cuttings of things they had nothing to do with, I agree it's dumb to see them do that... deserving of eye rolling... but it's so widespread that I'm surprised anybody would be surprised or shocked by it.

Mayor Brown is famous or infamous for it (Price Rite, New Era, Labatt).

From her wording it soulds like she's hinting it's Collins this time ("major regional political office"), but it's very common.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Not Collins...this time (though you might really think I'd have a tendency to go that way after you see what I just posted), but this really is a general sort of thing despite the one incident that sparked it.

It's no secret that people trying to move projects are greatly helped when someone with political pull and/or access to dollars buys into the front end of a deal. Waiting for a sure bet to put your face on seems predatory as opposed to helpful.


replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

We have the exact same version of the Little Red Hen and read it to our kids every now and then. They like it. It's a good lesson for children.


And Heather, the dog, goat and pig do not say to the hen: "I'm too busy doing __________." No, they just don't feel like working. They could do things much more easily than she (like take the wheat to the miller, cut the wheat, etc.), but simply don't feel like it. Kind of like many ne'er do wells who don't want to study in school, don't want to work their way up the food chain from minimum wage, don't want to learn skills, but insist that the world owes them. They have the likes of you to bolster their state of victimhood.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Glad BRO brought this story to light but it shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. This sort of thing happens all the time from both sides of the aisle. It's pathetic, counter-productive and sometimes can even endanger the project from actually being completed. Whats worse is that it takes all the attention away from the people and organizations that actually did all the work.

you should have photo-shopped a picture of Byron at his infamous podium into that last chicken little picture.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think that learning the lesson of the little red hen is a tough one. While you're expecting a pat on the back for getting the job done, someone or a whole bunch of someones is/are throwing you to the back of the room---not always politicans---while they bask in the glory of a project that you completed. There's an old saying that says that success has many mothers and failure has just one. No wonder there are so many red hens out there who won't put themselves through that again. Yet, there are still others who learn to just focus on the merits of the project and ignore everyone else. To all of the red hens out there, I say: believe in what you're doing and smile from the back of the room that your project is so wonderful that every a**hole tries to take credit. The ones who really count know better, because they were there.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

This reminds me of a local who recently took credit for years of other peoples work sayiong that the figurehead was working as a substitute for a bunch of people that were to afraid of taking a stand. Ain't further from the truth but hes got his bandwagon playing the field out there. toot, toot, look at me the hometown hero, toot, toot.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll