City March 20, 2009 10:20 AM

Stimulus to Help Buffalo Public Schools

Stimulus to Help Buffalo Public Schools

Last week, Superintendent of Buffalo Public Schools Dr. James Williams went to Washington to meet with 30 fellow urban school superintendents from across the nation in a roundtable discussion with Secretary of Education Arne Duncan and Obama Administration officials at the White House. They discussed how to make the most of a $100 billion stimulus package, that Buffalo will see a share of, in order to improve and advance public education. 

According to Williams, Buffalo will get 50 percent of the allotment (total amount as yet undisclosed) by the end of March.  The remainder will come 6 months later with certain stipulations, key of which is a William's ability to prove that there is agreement between the superintendent and the unions.  In the past, there has been a strained relationship between Williams and Buffalo Teachers Federation President Phil Rumore, and now that stimulus dollars are hanging in the balance, it is hoped that differences will be settled in order to take advantage of the available funds.

In order to maximize the stimulus dollars, the superintendents spoke with Arne about longer school days and a longer school year, which Williams has made operational in 17 schools since he began his tenure in Buffalo.  Williams also had the distinction of being the senior superintendent at the meeting, with 20 years experience.

Expanding on the topic of discussion, Williams said, "We have to build an agenda.  We have to close schools that aren't performing, of which there will be 11 in Buffalo this year.  We need a data base to track each individual student.  We also talked about recycling teachers in non-performing schools and teacher quality.  If you recycle teachers and children, you move away from blaming the school.  I've started these processes an procedures."

Another stipulation for the stimulus funds is that they not be used on personnel.

Williams says that Arne raised the topic of problems with unions and the importance of collaboration for change.  In agreement with everything Arne had to say, Williams, who has long held the same ideals said, "It was like I wrote it."  There was a general corroboration among the superintendents that common problems in public schools are universal throughout the nation.  

When Williams was asked if poverty in Buffalo played into student performance, he said, "Poverty is used as an excuse; we blame the poverty.  We'll get out of poverty by educating children."

The money is more important than ever with Williams, who worries about losing ground due to the economy as well as a change in administration.  He says Albany sometimes gets "confused" in an administrative change and that the fiscal crisis make it all the more difficult to do business.  He's not expecting the state budget to be done April 1st of this year.

"The economy won't be back to normal in 2 years," Williams said.  "We have $24 million coming from Title 1, $14 from the IDEA (Individuals with Disabilities Act), and the stimulus package will be separate from that.  It will balance whatever Governor Paterson comes up with.  We were used to a multi-year budget under Spitzer.  All supers need to tighten up controls." 

Williams says the bottom line is collaboration and working together for the children, then the government will show us the money.

 


View image

Comments

Leave a comment

"Poverty is used as an excuse; we blame the poverty. We'll get out of poverty by educating children."
---
Poverty may be an excuse, but hunger isn't. Our system owes school children access to a decent meal, something Buffalo Public School students don't have regardless of income or neighborhood.

No one ever said school lunch had to be tasty, but it ought to be relatively nutritious and healthy. Right now the vast majority of poorly concocted, pre-fab breakfast and lunch meals served to Buffalo students end up in the cafeteria trash can, and rightly so.

I'd like to see some of the stimulus go to feeding our kids. How can you be a good, attentive student when you're diet consists of a small amount of simple carbs and zero brain food?

This is especially true if the system begins to have longer school days (an idea I support). While they're at it, maybe they could let the kids play on the playground more than once a month and take part in gym more than once every six days? I think that all of those things would increase attendance and performance in our schools.

Thanks for listening. Back to work now...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

ChristaSeychew>"Our system owes school children access to a decent meal, something Buffalo Public School students don't have regardless of income or neighborhood.

ChristaSeychew>"Right now the vast majority of poorly concocted, pre-fab breakfast and lunch meals served to Buffalo students end up in the cafeteria trash can."

Those are very strong public accusations. Meals not "decent", "vast majority" thrown in trash.

Evidence, please?

replied to ChristaSeychew
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Having had 3 children in the Buffalo Public Schools I can attest to the poor quality of lunches. Outsourcing to the private sector put profits ahead of quality.(remember when the Reagan Administration tried to classify ketchup as a vegetable) My kids usually took a lunch from home.

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

look at Willimas, that bum, he look like he be smokin that crack, his eye be all out of whack.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I maintain you will not be very successful teaching large groups of children with screwed up home lifes and neighborhoods. That drama creeps into the classroom and wrecks the learning experience, makes learning and teaching second class. Inner city teachers often too busy dealing with the drama and interferences to do their jobs.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I totally agree with Christa. I have a child in the Buffalo Public Schools, and as it is, there is no way I'd allow her to eat the lunch they serve there. I'm grateful that I can afford (time and money) to send her in with a healthy meal everyday. The slop they serve at her school (#64) comes from a box, is heated up in the morning at an off premise central commissary, then kept warm in a plastic tray until service time. I've see the menu every month, and I've seen the food in person. It's over-processed, no nutrient, high glycemic, carb filler at best. It's no wonder these kids are bouncing off the walls. Across the country, schools that have started offering fresh, whole foods with balanced ratios (carb/fat/protein) have almost instantly seen the attendance level increase (less sick kids), as well as witness attention spans multiply exponentially.

The lack of unstructured playtime, particularly outdoors in another issue that is truly frightening to me. This is where socialization occurs. My child is in kindergarten, and she is allowed playground time only two out of every six days. WTF??? The teacher said she wishes they could do it every day (because she knows the kids ALWAYS focus better after some release) but Williams and his block of the school board are such structure disciples that there is no time alloted for this type of experience. It's all about dibels, and discipline, and dollars with this current Williams block of the school board majority. I'm scared for what the future holds...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

And just think, Hoss, our kids go to one of the best schools in the city. I can't imagine what some of the schools that will be closed this year must be like.

I understand whatever's cry for evidence. I wish I had some to offer that could be transcribed here in this little grey box. Unfortunately, the evidence gets taken out with the trash every day. Perhaps I could offer up a sample of the processed, packaged food being offered at school--Hostess mini muffins and fruity pebbles for breakfast, Smucker's brand 'uncrustable' sandwiches for lunch... you get the idea.

When I was a kid, lunch didn't always taste good, but at least it was made out of food.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I didn't say it's untrue, just asking if there's evidence. If indeed as Christa wrote the "vast majority" of the food (60%, 70%? what's being said here?) is every day being thrown in the trash then this should be brought to public attention and somebody held to account.

Who selects and oversees the food vendor(s)? The Board of Ed (i.e. Williams), or the feds?

What quality control checks are there, and how often, and what happens when problems are found?

Have any Buffalo Board of Ed members spoken out about this? Theres at least three members not blindly loyal to Williams. Mr. Hernandez? Ms. Cahill? What's their reaction to these charges? Have any parents attended Board of Ed meetings and raised this issue on the public record? It sounds like something the TV stations would love to cover.

How come I've never seen any letters to the editor in the Buffalo News about 60 or 70% of school lunches being thrown in the trash every day due to low quality? Some adults would be aware of it. Does this happen at City Honors?

Are there similar problems with federally funded school lunches in Amherst or Cheektowaga schools? What about in Buffalo charter schools and Catholic schools? Do all those systems use the same food vendors as the BPS does? Are the vast majority of federally funded lunches thrown in the trash every day in Buffalo charters, parochials, and in Amherst and Cheektowaga too?

I agree that if true, this is a serious problem on many levels.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

$1 billion? That barely covers the pedicure tab for these school administrators.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I've come to the conclusion that common sense is not very common!
When I attended school a daily menu was Soup, Sandwich, Fruit, Milk and a Dixie cup of ice cream. With today's whole wheat bread and low sodium soups, I think that is plenty. We've gotten too many choices and too many "poor me" additudes. How hard is it to give two options and that's that. If your kid doesn't like what you have - remember a lunch menu is sent home each month - then pack something!
As far as recess (Gym) goes, it should be every day and school should start at 7:30am and end at 5pm with longer classes and Art, Music and Gym mixed in! How did we get so far off of the reason that children are in school, that is to learn (Reading, Writing, Math, Science and History) and PARENTS CAN WORK FULL DAYS, COME ON, STEP UP TO THE PLATE BE A PARENT!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

School lunches in the sixties were prepared on site. Some type of meat, starch, and a vegetable with fruit for dessert. Not always top quality but at least not processed like today's prepackaged crap. Feeding our kids chicken nuggets, hot dogs, and other foods loaded with preservatives can't be good. Why not get kids used to eating healthy foods before they develop bad habits.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

@ timatbuffalo,

I pack my kids lunch every day. But not everyone in Buffalo has access to healthy foods or the ability to pay for them (and that issue will only increase as the economy Continues to struggle), which is why I brought the lunch issue up to begin with. Dr. Williams sited poverty as a poor excuse for poor performance in schools. I'm suggesting that hunger and inadequate nutrition (both a side effect of poverty) may be part of the problem.

@ whatever,
I'd love to do some detective work on this issue, but I'm focusing my energies on other parts of the WNY food chain at the moment. Other organizations in the area are working to help charter schools, private schools and, yes, public schools, develop healthier food programs. There is a ton of data available online about the effects of the current lunch system here in the US and in the UK, as well as a wealth of innovative solutions that have worked in other parts of the country.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I wasn't suggesting you should investigate all that. But it's difficult for me to believe nobody would be complaining publicly (no parents at board meetings ranting about this, no parents raising the issue in the media, no board members being phoned about it, etc., etc.) if it really is as bad as your first comment says and the majority of food isn't eaten due to low quality.

I wonder if you've at least notified the Board of Ed district rep of what you notified us on this blog? You're helping pay his or her salary, obviously, so he or she should take your complaint seriously. I agree with your point about hunger impacts, but it's inexcusable with the amount of money spent for these school lunches that the kids are sitting there with empty stomachs every day at 2pm. Something doesn't add up.

replied to ChristaSeychew
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Here's a comparison. Many including me were mad about snow plowing quality a few times this past winter. After one storm, there were something like 4000 phone calls to the City Hall 311 line about it. After that, the mayor and streets commissioner responded publicly, admitting low quality of plowing, promising investigation and changes. Next similar storm, I noticed improvements, Time will tell whether improvement was a one time fluke or if they made serious chages.

Point is, citizen complaints can have some affect, so maybe for the school lunch situation they could also.

Why isn't there a "311" type of phone line for the Buffalo school system? Probably there should be, but even without that there are ways for parents to raise school-related issues and be heard.

replied to ChristaSeychew
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"Why isn't there a "311" type of phone line for the Buffalo school system? Probably there should be, but even without that there are ways for parents to raise school-related issues and be heard."

Why isn't there a 911 phone line so parents that regard the public schools as little more than free daycare can connect with lawyers every time their little angels are challenged by a new concept or are corrected when they behave like animals?

replied to whatever
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Two different issues. Many parents do regard public schools they way you describe, and that will get worse over time as the government provides more and more for people.

I imagine in 20 or 30 years, govt will have taken over even more parental responsibilities - maybe providing 3 meals/day for most city kids all 365 days of the year. That's a logical extension of trends we're on. Lunch, breakfast, pre-K, after hours programs, summer meals and supervision, ... on and on. Probably within 10 years the schools will be serving suppers too, and after a few years of that people will wonder how city families ever survived without it. Within 20 years, the government will be supplying kids clothing as well as meals.

I agree all that's troubling, but it really doesn't excuse the problem Christa says is happening.

As much as it may indicate societal problems to realize many parents wouldn't prepare basic lunches every day even if given money for it (extra food stamps, for example), there's still no excuse for public money to be wasted on majorly crappy uneatable meals that results in 60 or 70% of it being thrown in the trash (which I'm still skeptical about, but she insists it's really what's happening).

Long term trends are probably irreversable at this point but as I said, parents can and should complain loudy about more narrow solvable problems. Making Buffalo parents more responsible against their will won't happen no matter what, but that's no reason to trash a lot of food every day and have the kids be hungry anyway.

replied to sonyactivision
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Full-scale integrated busing was begun in the city in 1977. Back then, City Honors and the other Magnet schools served nutritious lunches that were prepared on-site--in 1977 and before that, there were very few or no school breakfasts yet.
.
Keep in mind, that when full busing first started, there were two kinds of systems involved; the Magnet schools and the former neighborhood schools.
.
Back then, the city neighborhood schools did not have the facilities for prepared meals--most city schools were so "neighborhood" that the kids either brought their lunches from home and ate at their desks, or went home during recess to eat lunch.
.
In the olden days, I went home for lunch and no kids back then EVER talked about lunch outside of school. So it surprises me that when we are around our grands and their friends, the school "food" must be so bad that the kids today bring up the yuck factor in away-from-school everyday kid conversations!!!
.
These days, especially in the city, taxpayers are paying for pre-packaged trash-tossed school "meals" that, tossed in with poor home environment, are conducive only to guaranteed poor learning ability and poor health.
.
Those poor quality school "meals" that do get eaten, and the serious lack of "gym" or "recess", are the direct cause of obesity in children--including that they then go home to poor-parenting junk "foods" and more pre-packaged "dinners" they never get to physically work off.
.
Are Raymond's nutritionally devoid packaged "soups" still what lazy moms tell their half-starved kiddies to fix for themselves?
.
As far as the food quality or lack of in the first-ring suburban schools, suburban parents would have to volunteer that information--but many of those kids also say yuck.


Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

OK...who lives in any city USA and sends their kids to public schools?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Wow! Bailout money for the Bflo Schools! I bet the teachers union can't wait for the pay raises, and just maybe some more benefits and pension perks. WooHoo!
.
I have a better idea! Let’s take the money and fund new projects that we could not possibly afford to keep after the fed money is gone... now that sounds like the buffalo school system we all know and love!
.
Maybe one day, just maybe someone in the system will realize that it about our kids and hire a 'Michelle Rhee', though I am sure that the Bflo school district would be struggling with crisis even if their were no students at all.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

feed our kids. we can barely teach them. anybody remember lunch boxes? parents should prepare and send lunch with there kids, stop putting the burden on the education system, they should not supply anything more than an education!! if a good meal is such a concern, than make it yourself and quit your whining!!! YES, i made lunch for my son everyday to bring to school.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

School lunches are federally funded. The problems cited above are universal across the nation. So is the dialogue here. Having spent decades in the public schools, I can tell you that much of it is thrown away by the kids. But, most of it is eaten. When they started serving breakfast in the 80's (by mandate), there was a large public outcry about taxes and the entire school lunch program. The kids did eat the parts they considered edible and there was a discernable difference immediately in their performance and behavior. What they ate for breakfast was far better than nothing at all.

Having worked in a high poverty school, I have often seen Kindergarten parents sharing the lunches that rightly belong to the kids. Often.

In large school districts, food is prepared in central locations. By design, school kitchens are no longer equipped to prepare complete meals. I don't want to get into the debate that kids who live in poverty can learn just as well as any other kid. I don't want to engage in that fruitless debate because critics of the public schools usually have never spent time in the trenches. For them, it is all about ideology and ignorance. No insults intended.

But, those who have had children who have participated in the federally funded program have a great deal of knowledge from those who know the most- the kids. There are many days in the week when they look forward to the meals. Some kids even pay! Many times, so do the staff members.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Pegger,

I see your point, and as a former public school student who physically survived almost *entirely* on free school lunches for all of 6-12, I agree that a lunch program is important, and for hungry kids, absolutely necessary.

My point in all of this is that Dr. Williams' statement regarding the 11 city schools that will close due to poor performance ["Poverty is used as an excuse; we blame the poverty. We'll get out of poverty by educating children".]does not take into consideration that poor nutrition and hunger(which are side effects of poverty)may be a very important part of the problem.

And, as you stated, the whole school lunch system is under scrutiny across the country. New York State even has a farm-to-school program (which is still in its early stages best I can tell), and legislation was recently put in place allowing school systems to spend more money on non-processed food grown in NY. (Which mos likely means that our kids will be eating apples from NY instead of Washington.)

However, at this stage in the game, those are band-aids on the very deep and widening wound of the U.S. food system, and school lunches are only one small component of a much larger issue. But that's a story for another day.

I would like to apologize for accidentally hijacking this conversation and turning it into a discussion about school lunches. It was a knee-jerk reaction to hearing Dr. Williams quote regarding poverty. I'd love to talk about food, or the local food system, or school lunches with anyone interested in the subject, but this is perhaps not the best place for that.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Christa,

Thanks for the thoughtful response.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll