City February 23, 2009 5:09 PM

St. Mary's On The Hill

St. Mary’s On The Hill
Now that we're seeing some warmer days, I'm hopeful that St. Mary's On The Hill will continue to hang in there (see back story). I wasn't quite sure if the building was going to last until spring. With each passing day the community continues to hold its collective breath in hopes that a new owner can be found who has the resources to shore up the walls and add a roof. Fortunately, there is a joint effort underway to locate an investor who can complete the task at hand. From Harvey Garrett of the West Side Community Collaborative (WSCC):

"We have some real good options. We have a few interested parties looking at it. We're looking at stabilizing the building - stabilizing the roof alone would cost $70,000. At the same time, that's how much it would cost to demolish the front section of the church. That means that it is in The City's best interest to leave the church standing. Of course there is a serious concern that the walls could fall on the building next door. Everyone is working together to save the building - The City, preservationists, the community. It's the only way to get this done. Everyone is realizing that we all have the same hopes and concerns. City Hall is legally responsible if something happens to someone due to the building's weakened condition. It's a battle of time. The building could last a day, or it could last three weeks or more. We need to save the property by finding a new owner. It's looking hopeful.

"The best outcome would be to save the building in order to save The City money, while having a viable building at the same time. We're not really sure what the current owner's reasons are for owning this church. They told us that the plan was to build a daycare center. They've owned the building for two years. Now the time line depends on the building. It could fall down tomorrow. The City inspectors are checking it every day. As soon as the bricks start to fall, then we've lost the battle. We're hoping that the building does not become a safety issue. Once again, everyone, including The City, is working towards saving the structure."

View image

3 TrackBacks

TrackBack URL: http://www.buffalorising.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/722

Did you happen to hear that The National Trust for Historic Preservation named Buffalo one of the 2009 Dozen Distinctive Destinations. Did you know that the National Preservation Conference will be hosted in Buffalo in 2011? Did anyone tell The City th... Read More

Sam Savarino is interested in buying and converting the ravaged St. Mary's-on-the-Hill Church in the Prospect Heights neighborhood into residences, if he can purchase the property from an out-of-town owner.  The landmarked circa-1903 church, or wh... Read More

Despite Sam Savarino's interest in converting the ravaged St. Mary's-on-the-Hill Church into residences, the City is moving forward with an emergency demolition order.  The landmarked circa-1903 church, now just a roofless shell, is located at the... Read More

Comments

Leave a comment

Breathing a careful sigh of relief that this building has indeed survived the worst (knock on wood) that this winter could throw at it.


Could some funding assistance from the Preservation League's Endangered Properties Intervention Program help sweeten the pot for a responsible investor--?


Ref:
http://archives.buffalorising.com/story/preservation_league_rolls_out


Ref:
http://archives.buffalorising.com/story/jay_dilorenzo_on_preservation_1

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I think there are a lot of potential funding sources but we need to find a good (probably local) owner first that is willing to take responsibility for the building and it's future. We don't have anything definite yet but we have some very interested parties and we are hopeful.

As Newell mentioned in the post everyone is working together on this one.

Harvey

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Is there a comprehensive list of historically significant buildings that are in need of saving by a new owner or group of investors? It seems that we usually find out about the dire straights of these properties in the 11th hour, why can't we find out about them sooner? Does the Preservation League have a list of "at risk" properties that could use a new owner? Has the City made it easier to purchase properties and mitigated the risks associated with buying then (fines, citations, etc)?


We could really use some leadership from the Preservation Board or the City to focus attention on these properties before it is too late.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Whynot, your comment is very timely. The newly formed preservation group Preservation Buffalo Niagara considers that shift to a proactive approach one of its critical missions. Stay tuned to BR for some news about that...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll