City January 19, 2009 2:35 PM

Porter Avenue to be restored as an Olmsted Parkway in 2009

Porter Avenue to be restored as an Olmsted Parkway in 2009
BRO submission by Chris Brown:

Heavily-utilized Porter Avenue, one of Buffalo's most historic streets, is scheduled to receive a $1.8 million make-over in 2009 to return it to its former splendor as an Olmsted Parkway.

Porter Avenue is one of Buffalo's oldest streets, pre-dating Joseph Ellicott's design for the village. It was once an ancient Indian trail, in use since the Revolutionary War. It was called "Guide Board Road," and was a passage from Main Street to the Niagara River and a ferry that would carry British loyalists to safety in Canada. The street was later called North Street, being the northern-most boundary of the Village of Buffalo at the time of its creation.

The street played a prominent role during the War of 1812 when the British and their Mohawk Indian allies arrived on Dec. 30 1813 to burn the villages of Buffalo and Black Rock to the ground. It was one of the few streets that were in use during that early time and the British used it to invade. A battle was fought on the street, approximately between where West and Plymouth Avenues intersect today, and it was a bloody defeat for the Americans. The street was laid waste with dead, scalped soldiers' bodies. A=2 0historic marker erected on Porter Avenue in 2008 commemorates the bravery of Job Hoisington, a Buffalo militia-man, who attempted to hold back the British during the conflict.

The street layout was changed in the 1820s, its original route, which continued in a straight line westerly beyond West Avenue, was terminated when the old Black Rock streets were laid out. In the layout, York Street intersected the street at West Avenue.

As a thoroughfare, the street grew significantly in prominence during the late 1860s when Frederick Law Olmsted "created" Porter Avenue by utilizing the portion of York Street from the Niagara River to West Avenue and then the portion of North Street from West Avenue to Richmond, calling it "Porter," named for Fort Porter, at the northern boundary of his new park, "The Front." Porter Avenue would connect The Front to Symphony Circle and Richmond Avenue, and ultimately to Delaware Park.

As the decades passed, Porter Avenue became home to beautiful mansions, stately public architecture and the world-famous Kleinhans Music Hall. The street is listed on the National Register of Historic Places by virtue of it being part of the Buffalo Olmsted park system. A portion of the street is also included in the Allentown Historic Preservation District.

Despite all this grand history, Porter Avenue, especially the portion between Symphony Circle and the Niagara River, has been neglected during the past several decades, but no more.

The City of Buffalo will be implementing major improvements to Porter Avenue between Niagara Street and Symphony Circle in 2009. The project which is being overseen by the City of Buffalo's Department of Public Works, has contracted Watts Architecture & Engineering to prepare the design and associated studies for the reconstruction. This is a federal-aid project, requested by the Mayor's Office and Niagara District Councilman.

The project's goal is to restore look of Porter Avenue as historic Olmsted parkway as much as possible.

The scope of the work is expected to include:

- a mill-and-inlay of the pavement (not full-depth reconstruction)

- replacement of the sidewalks, curbs, gutters, hydrants, drainage inlets

- lighting

In addition, approximately 45 new trees will be planted along Porter Avenue. The new sidewalks will be made of exposed aggregate. All existing 100+ year-old slate sidewalks are planned to be removed and it is hoped that the existing slate sidewalks will be reused at bus stops. The new lighting will be the historic-style "Central Park" luminaires (like those in Symphony Circle).

It is expected that there will be crosswalks at major intersections; the intersection of Porter/Jersey/Normal is particularly dangerous. The newly constructed roadway will include one lane for cars, a bike path, and parking on both sides of street. Retention of the brick gutter alongside the curb in the roadway will also be accomplished, a distinctive feature of Porter Avenue.

The Olmsted Conservancy, who is participating in the Porter Avenue reconstruction, would like to see a uniform parkway from Niagara St. to Symphony Circle. The parkway "right of way" includes sidewalks, the grassy area from sidewalk to curb line and a few feet of what people consider their "front lawn." Design elements that the Conservancy believes are inappropriate in lawn area include (but not limited to): privet hedges, fencing, etc.

The project team also includes representatives from Wendell Duscherer, who is also reconstructing Porter Avenue from the I-190 Thruway to the Niagara River/LaSalle Park. The team hopes to begin construction in July 2009 with completion 4-5 months later.

A public informational meeting will be held on Thursday, Feb. 5, 2009 from 5-7 PM at D'Youville College, Madonna Lounge, inside Madonna Hall. From 5 to 6 PM there will be an open house where attendees can discuss the project with City of Buffalo staff and the design consultant team. A short presentation of the project will be given at PM with questions and comments following.

For such an important street, it is high-time that these improvements are taking place. It is often the first impression of Buffalo that visitors receive after crossing the Peace Bridge from Canada.

Related Articles:

The Birge Mansion - Then and Now

Four Corner Improvement Project

Olmsted's Corridor Of Light

Cinderella of Symphony Circle
View image

Comments

Leave a comment

Chris, a great, well-written article. Keep up the good work. Thank you for this information.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Great!

But it sounds like, as is the norm with these projects, that they may cut down trees on Porter, DO NOT CUT DOWN ANY MATURE TREES!!!!! There is absolutely no reason to cut down those trees, they are the best part of the street. Imagine Bidwell parkway without trees, Richmond avenue sans the beautiful fall foliage.... colossal mistake!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

great article, this is amazing news!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

"The project's goal is to restore look of Porter Avenue as historic Olmsted parkway as much as possible."

One thing I don't like about this project is the removal of the slate sidewalks! Thats what makes Richmond look so nice. Yes granted they may not be level. If they are going to take the time to dig them all out to put new aggregate in, how hard would it be to relevel to ground and fill in the few spots that are missing the slate? I think it would be cheaper and save time rather than digging them all up and putting new in. There going to have to dig them up anyway to level the soil for what ever new cheap side walk there going to put in.

Besides the rant on the side walks. I hope this all looks nice.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If they're only planting 45 trees, I doubt they're taking out any healthy mature trees.

As for the sidewalks - what were they composed of in Olmsted's original plan? Would hate to lose the slate if they're still functional.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A long time in the making but I am glad it is finally here. Will definitely help to tie Front Park back into the larger Olmsted Park and Parkway system. Think about biking down Richmond, hitting Symphony Circle, saying... in Urban Design speak.. go down Porter (another parkway) and you will find another park and the river.


All of our historic elements were placed for very specific reasons. The circle at Ferry tells you again where a direct path to the water from Olmsted's system exists and Colonial circle tells you that this is a transition \ gateway to Delaware Park and it's parkways from the Avenue.


Can't wait for it to finally be a single, unified and beautiful path from Delaware park all the way to The Front!

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Chris, this is phenomenal news - congrats to everyone in Allentown and Kleinhans Neighborhoods who have worked to get this in motion.


We've had several street projects in My Fair City where the slate (sandstone, here) sidewalks were taken up, and returned to the site after regrading. Often many pavers are broken, so the remaining good ones are sometimes consolidated in particular locations - say, in front of a notable older building or landmark.


What about bumpouts near cross streets - are those in the plan--? Bumpouts help delineate streetside parking areas and help protect cars from sideswipes - they also significantly shorten crossing distances for pedestrians, making it much easier and safer for pedestrians to circulate on a given block. And streetside parking has a traffic calming effect and reduces pressure for surface parking lots.


I know that Buffalo City Hall has historically been resistant to bumpouts, but we've had such positive experience with them here (and we get snow, too!) that we're now installing them as a matter of course when streets come up for periodic reconstruction -- and even retrofitting them into other streets. They're something worth fighting for (and we did have to conduct something of a campaign here to get them used initially - I can tell you more if you're interested).

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

I didn't know Porter carried such a rich history. Very cool

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

If you delve deep enough you can find such stories for hundred of streets and neighborhoods within the city. Part of what gives us that layered history worth saving... even if we might have forgotten why for the moment.


I also feel it is these kinds of stories that build pride and culture for a place. A culture, history and city that endure and become stronger as more stories are told.

replied to Andrew
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

sbrof- very well said.

replied to Sean Brodfuehrer
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

anyone looking for the background planning information that went into making this project happen years ago should look at the Queen City Waterfront document.


http://urbandesignproject.ap.buffalo.edu/projects/wci/QCW_Volume1_Strategy.pdf


Go to page 90ish for the section of Porter Avenue. Other information can be found in Volume 7 for the extended EPP for Porter Avenue


http://urbandesignproject.ap.buffalo.edu/projects/wci/QCW_Volume7_Porter.pdf

These planning documents finalized in 2007, and worked on for probably the three years prior are what setup the transportation and planning goals for the waterfront of the city. I am glad to see the Brown Admin hasn't been able to throw everything away that was worked on before him.


Now if we could only force him to read and adhere to these documents, then such things like Erie Street, bump outs, and Wingate hotels fiascoes wouldn't happen. Great work to everyone and Wendell Duscherer for kept this project moving.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Good story Chris-It is wonderful to see another project that will restore some of the beauty that once made Buffalo a very desirable place to live. The new appreciation and investment in preservation has finally turned the tide against decades of poor planning. 20 or 30 years ago a project like this would not have even been considered. It is the energy and commitment of a new generation of urban advocates that have made a difference.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Porter Avenue reconstruction is long overdue and it should have an impact on property values both along the street and the adjacent side streets (I consider Porter the real border between the so called west village and the westside)

The period lighting is the most significant addition that will add visibly to the curb appeal of the properties on Porter. The full effect requires period lighting on the side streets also...and rebricking the sidestreets would provide another boost to curb appeal and property values.

Unfortunately, Niagara Street Gateway Project, Columbus and Front Park are being held hostage to the Peace Bridge.

Our focus is then forced upon those areas such as Porter, Grant, Ferry, Connecticut, Forest, Amherst and Tonawanda (all of which need similar infill and investments to raise property values).

Driving along Porter, one can see that there are still many homes decayed and in danger...of which...we can only hope that this street investment raises the curb appeal and property values enough to attract the homesteaders who will pump the money into their maintenance and upkeep.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Awesome! I'd love it if Princeton Elms were planted. Ya gotta have Elms along historic avenues...

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Especially Olsmted avenues. I understand the need to keep away from a monoculture within the city... but how great would it be to move through the olmsted parks, parkways and then avenues following huge, stately elms as your shade.


The trees with the urban design elements would basically tell you which direction to go. Love that idea too bad the city won't do it again. I find it funny how they say they don't want a monoculture but if you look at most new streets they are almost exactly that, Kentucky Coffee Trees or Maples... that's all I see get planted anymore.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

The more I read this the more it sounds like the city cutting corners. Mill and inlay of the road? that's just scrapping the surface down a few inches and putting a new topping down. Why not do it right and tear it all up so it doesn't break up in 10-15 years. Or go down to the old brick road and make this road truly look stately with a brick road like the end of Niagara falls boulevard at main. The only thing that might look nice coming in will be the lighting.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

It's a $1.8 million project, not an $18 million one and the city just doesn't have the money to do an over-the-top historic reconstruction. But there's nothing stopping you, Jalopy, from initiating a major endowment for streets and parks:)

replied to jolopy
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Lol. I wish I was able to initiate a major endowment for the area. All I can afford to do is finish my masters and continue to set an example by fixing my home and presenting it as the standard I expect all my neighbors to hold to their own homes. Most improvements are always beneficial to the area, I just hope I can snag a few of those slate sidewalks for my back yard:-)

replied to sonyactivision
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Its about time. I ride this stretch 3-4 times a week on a bicycle and it's an accident waiting to happen. Barely a shoulder to ride on and what is there consists of potholes and chewed up asphalt.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

A bike lane! They actually have that in the plan!
Now if we could just figure out a way to plow them in the winter for us year round commuters.
But it is sure refreshing to see a plan that takes the historical and much needed modern infrastructure into account...nice job.

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

there isn't anything stopping a plow from plowing a bike lane compared to a car lane... the only thing that could get in the way is the plow driver's laziness.

replied to FredOak
Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

BUMP.

July came and went....been trying to find out whats going on here. Any ideas?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Beautiful, maybe they can finish in time to tear it up for the new peace bridge toll plazas

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Has this happened?

Score: 0 ( 0 votes ) Vote up Vote down Report this comment

Leave a comment

Buffalo Rising Poll